example-cycles.md

title	description	zone_pivot_groups	author	ms.topic	ms.author	ms.date	ms.service
How-To: Author-Critic Pattern with Cycles	A step-by-step walk-through for using Cycles	programming-languages	bentho	tutorial	bentho	01/13/2025	semantic-kernel

How-To: Using Cycles

Warning

The Semantic Kernel Process Framework is experimental, still in development and is subject to change.

Overview

In the previous section we built a simple Process to help us automate the creation of documentation for our new product. In this section we will improve on that process by adding a proofreading step. This step will use and LLM to grade the generated documentation as Pass/Fail, and provide recommended changes if needed. By taking advantage of the Process Frameworks' support for cycles, we can go one step further and automatically apply the recommended changes (if any) and then start the cycle over, repeating this until the content meets our quality bar. The updated process will look like this:

Updates to the process

We need to create our new proofreader step and also make a couple changes to our document generation step that will allow us to apply suggestions if needed.

Add the proofreader step

::: zone pivot="programming-language-csharp"

// A process step to proofread documentation
public class ProofreadStep : KernelProcessStep
{
    [KernelFunction]
    public async Task ProofreadDocumentationAsync(Kernel kernel, KernelProcessStepContext context, string documentation)
    {
        Console.WriteLine($"{nameof(ProofreadDocumentationAsync)}:\n\tProofreading documentation...");

        var systemPrompt =
            """
        Your job is to proofread customer facing documentation for a new product from Contoso. You will be provide with proposed documentation
        for a product and you must do the following things:

        1. Determine if the documentation is passes the following criteria:
            1. Documentation must use a professional tone.
            1. Documentation should be free of spelling or grammar mistakes.
            1. Documentation should be free of any offensive or inappropriate language.
            1. Documentation should be technically accurate.
        2. If the documentation does not pass 1, you must write detailed feedback of the changes that are needed to improve the documentation. 
        """;

        ChatHistory chatHistory = new ChatHistory(systemPrompt);
        chatHistory.AddUserMessage(documentation);

        // Use structured output to ensure the response format is easily parsable
        OpenAIPromptExecutionSettings settings = new OpenAIPromptExecutionSettings();
        settings.ResponseFormat = typeof(ProofreadingResponse);

        IChatCompletionService chatCompletionService = kernel.GetRequiredService<IChatCompletionService>();
        var proofreadResponse = await chatCompletionService.GetChatMessageContentAsync(chatHistory, executionSettings: settings);
        var formattedResponse = JsonSerializer.Deserialize<ProofreadingResponse>(proofreadResponse.Content!.ToString());

        Console.WriteLine($"\n\tGrade: {(formattedResponse!.MeetsExpectations ? "Pass" : "Fail")}\n\tExplanation: {formattedResponse.Explanation}\n\tSuggestions: {string.Join("\n\t\t", formattedResponse.Suggestions)}");

        if (formattedResponse.MeetsExpectations)
        {
            await context.EmitEventAsync("DocumentationApproved", data: documentation);
        }
        else
        {
            await context.EmitEventAsync("DocumentationRejected", data: new { Explanation = formattedResponse.Explanation, Suggestions = formattedResponse.Suggestions});
        }
    }

    // A class 
    private class ProofreadingResponse
    {
        [Description("Specifies if the proposed documentation meets the expected standards for publishing.")]
        public bool MeetsExpectations { get; set; }

        [Description("An explanation of why the documentation does or does not meet expectations.")]
        public string Explanation { get; set; } = "";

        [Description("A lis of suggestions, may be empty if there no suggestions for improvement.")]
        public List<string> Suggestions { get; set; } = new();
    }
}

A new step named ProofreadStep has been created. This step uses the LLM to grade the generated documentation as discussed above. Notice that this step conditionally emits either the DocumentationApproved event or the DocumentationRejected event based on the response from the LLM. In the case of DocumentationApproved, the event will include the approved documentation as it's payload and in the case of DocumentationRejected it will include the suggestions from the proofreader. ::: zone-end

::: zone pivot="programming-language-python"

# A sample response model for the ProofreadingStep structured output
class ProofreadingResponse(BaseModel):
    """A class to represent the response from the proofreading step."""

    meets_expectations: bool = Field(description="Specifies if the proposed docs meets the standards for publishing.")
    explanation: str = Field(description="An explanation of why the documentation does or does not meet expectations.")
    suggestions: list[str] = Field(description="List of suggestions, empty if there are no suggestions for improvement.")

# A process step to proofread documentation
class ProofreadStep(KernelProcessStep):
    @kernel_function
    async def proofread_documentation(self, docs: str, context: KernelProcessStepContext, kernel: Kernel) -> None:
        print(f"{ProofreadStep.__name__}\n\t Proofreading product documentation...")

        system_prompt = """
        Your job is to proofread customer facing documentation for a new product from Contoso. You will be provided with 
        proposed documentation for a product and you must do the following things:

        1. Determine if the documentation passes the following criteria:
            1. Documentation must use a professional tone.
            1. Documentation should be free of spelling or grammar mistakes.
            1. Documentation should be free of any offensive or inappropriate language.
            1. Documentation should be technically accurate.
        2. If the documentation does not pass 1, you must write detailed feedback of the changes that are needed to 
            improve the documentation. 
        """

        chat_history = ChatHistory(system_message=system_prompt)
        chat_history.add_user_message(docs)

        # Use structured output to ensure the response format is easily parsable
        chat_service, settings = kernel.select_ai_service(type=ChatCompletionClientBase)
        assert isinstance(chat_service, ChatCompletionClientBase)  # nosec
        assert isinstance(settings, OpenAIChatPromptExecutionSettings)  # nosec

        settings.response_format = ProofreadingResponse

        response = await chat_service.get_chat_message_content(chat_history=chat_history, settings=settings)

        formatted_response: ProofreadingResponse = ProofreadingResponse.model_validate_json(response.content)

        suggestions_text = "\n\t\t".join(formatted_response.suggestions)
        print(
            f"\n\tGrade: {'Pass' if formatted_response.meets_expectations else 'Fail'}\n\t"
            f"Explanation: {formatted_response.explanation}\n\t"
            f"Suggestions: {suggestions_text}"
        )

        if formatted_response.meets_expectations:
            await context.emit_event(process_event="documentation_approved", data=docs)
        else:
            await context.emit_event(
                process_event="documentation_rejected",
                data="suggestions_text",
            )

A new step named ProofreadStep has been created. This step uses the LLM to grade the generated documentation as discussed above. Notice that this step conditionally emits either the documentation_approved event or the documentation_rejected event based on the response from the LLM. In the case of documentation_approved, the event will include the approved documentation as it's payload and in the case of documentation_rejected it will include the suggestions from the proofreader. ::: zone-end

::: zone pivot="programming-language-java" ::: zone-end

Update the documentation generation step

::: zone pivot="programming-language-csharp"

// Updated process step to generate and edit documentation for a product
public class GenerateDocumentationStep : KernelProcessStep<GeneratedDocumentationState>
{
    private GeneratedDocumentationState _state = new();

    private string systemPrompt =
            """
            Your job is to write high quality and engaging customer facing documentation for a new product from Contoso. You will be provide with information
            about the product in the form of internal documentation, specs, and troubleshooting guides and you must use this information and
            nothing else to generate the documentation. If suggestions are provided on the documentation you create, take the suggestions into account and
            rewrite the documentation. Make sure the product sounds amazing.
            """;

    override public ValueTask ActivateAsync(KernelProcessStepState<GeneratedDocumentationState> state)
    {
        this._state = state.State!;
        this._state.ChatHistory ??= new ChatHistory(systemPrompt);

        return base.ActivateAsync(state);
    }

    [KernelFunction]
    public async Task GenerateDocumentationAsync(Kernel kernel, KernelProcessStepContext context, string productInfo)
    {
        Console.WriteLine($"{nameof(GenerateDocumentationStep)}:\n\tGenerating documentation for provided productInfo...");

        // Add the new product info to the chat history
        this._state.ChatHistory!.AddUserMessage($"Product Info:\n\n{productInfo}");

        // Get a response from the LLM
        IChatCompletionService chatCompletionService = kernel.GetRequiredService<IChatCompletionService>();
        var generatedDocumentationResponse = await chatCompletionService.GetChatMessageContentAsync(this._state.ChatHistory!);

        await context.EmitEventAsync("DocumentationGenerated", generatedDocumentationResponse.Content!.ToString());
    }

    [KernelFunction]
    public async Task ApplySuggestionsAsync(Kernel kernel, KernelProcessStepContext context, string suggestions)
    {
        Console.WriteLine($"{nameof(GenerateDocumentationStep)}:\n\tRewriting documentation with provided suggestions...");

        // Add the new product info to the chat history
        this._state.ChatHistory!.AddUserMessage($"Rewrite the documentation with the following suggestions:\n\n{suggestions}");

        // Get a response from the LLM
        IChatCompletionService chatCompletionService = kernel.GetRequiredService<IChatCompletionService>();
        var generatedDocumentationResponse = await chatCompletionService.GetChatMessageContentAsync(this._state.ChatHistory!);

        await context.EmitEventAsync("DocumentationGenerated", generatedDocumentationResponse.Content!.ToString());
    }

    public class GeneratedDocumentationState
    {
        public ChatHistory? ChatHistory { get; set; }
    }
}

The GenerateDocumentationStep has been updated to include a new KernelFunction. The new function will be used to apply suggested changes to the documentation if our proofreading step requires them. Notice that both functions for generating or rewriting documentation emit the same event named DocumentationGenerated indicating that new documentation is available. ::: zone-end

::: zone pivot="programming-language-python"

# Updated process step to generate and edit documentation for a product
class GenerateDocumentationStep(KernelProcessStep[GeneratedDocumentationState]):
    state: GeneratedDocumentationState = Field(default_factory=GeneratedDocumentationState)

    system_prompt: ClassVar[str] = """
Your job is to write high quality and engaging customer facing documentation for a new product from Contoso. You will 
be provided with information about the product in the form of internal documentation, specs, and troubleshooting guides 
and you must use this information and nothing else to generate the documentation. If suggestions are provided on the 
documentation you create, take the suggestions into account and rewrite the documentation. Make sure the product 
sounds amazing.
"""

    async def activate(self, state: KernelProcessStepState[GeneratedDocumentationState]):
        self.state = state.state
        if self.state.chat_history is None:
            self.state.chat_history = ChatHistory(system_message=self.system_prompt)
        self.state.chat_history

    @kernel_function
    async def generate_documentation(
        self, context: KernelProcessStepContext, product_info: str, kernel: Kernel
    ) -> None:
        print(f"{GenerateDocumentationStep.__name__}\n\t Generating documentation for provided product_info...")

        self.state.chat_history.add_user_message(f"Product Information:\n{product_info}")

        chat_service, settings = kernel.select_ai_service(type=ChatCompletionClientBase)
        assert isinstance(chat_service, ChatCompletionClientBase)  # nosec

        response = await chat_service.get_chat_message_content(chat_history=self.state.chat_history, settings=settings)

        await context.emit_event(process_event="documentation_generated", data=str(response))

    @kernel_function
    async def apply_suggestions(self, suggestions: str, context: KernelProcessStepContext, kernel: Kernel) -> None:
        print(f"{GenerateDocumentationStep.__name__}\n\t Rewriting documentation with provided suggestions...")

        self.state.chat_history.add_user_message(
            f"Rewrite the documentation with the following suggestions:\n\n{suggestions}"
        )

        chat_service, settings = kernel.select_ai_service(type=ChatCompletionClientBase)
        assert isinstance(chat_service, ChatCompletionClientBase)  # nosec

        generated_documentation_response = await chat_service.get_chat_message_content(
            chat_history=self.state.chat_history, settings=settings
        )

        await context.emit_event(process_event="documentation_generated", data=str(generated_documentation_response))

The GenerateDocumentationStep has been updated to include a new KernelFunction. The new function will be used to apply suggested changes to the documentation if our proofreading step requires them. Notice that both functions for generating or rewriting documentation emit the same event named documentation_generated indicating that new documentation is available. ::: zone-end

::: zone pivot="programming-language-java" ::: zone-end

Flow updates

::: zone pivot="programming-language-csharp"

// Create the process builder
ProcessBuilder processBuilder = new("DocumentationGeneration");

// Add the steps
var infoGatheringStep = processBuilder.AddStepFromType<GatherProductInfoStep>();
var docsGenerationStep = processBuilder.AddStepFromType<GenerateDocumentationStepV2>();
var docsProofreadStep = processBuilder.AddStepFromType<ProofreadStep>(); // Add new step here
var docsPublishStep = processBuilder.AddStepFromType<PublishDocumentationStep>();

// Orchestrate the events
processBuilder
    .OnInputEvent("Start")
    .SendEventTo(new(infoGatheringStep));

infoGatheringStep
    .OnFunctionResult()
    .SendEventTo(new(docsGenerationStep, functionName: "GenerateDocumentation"));

docsGenerationStep
    .OnEvent("DocumentationGenerated")
    .SendEventTo(new(docsProofreadStep));

docsProofreadStep
    .OnEvent("DocumentationRejected")
    .SendEventTo(new(docsGenerationStep, functionName: "ApplySuggestions"));

docsProofreadStep
    .OnEvent("DocumentationApproved")
    .SendEventTo(new(docsPublishStep));

var process = processBuilder.Build();
return process;

Our updated process routing now does the following:

• When an external event with id = Start is sent to the process, this event and its associated data will be sent to the infoGatheringStep.
• When the infoGatheringStep finishes running, send the returned object to the docsGenerationStep.
• When the docsGenerationStep finishes running, send the generated docs to the docsProofreadStep.
• When the docsProofreadStep rejects our documentation and provides suggestions, send the suggestions back to the docsGenerationStep.
• Finally, when the docsProofreadStep approves our documentation, send the returned object to the docsPublishStep. ::: zone-end

::: zone pivot="programming-language-python"

# Create the process builder
process_builder = ProcessBuilder(name="DocumentationGeneration")

# Add the steps
info_gathering_step = process_builder.add_step(GatherProductInfoStep)
docs_generation_step = process_builder.add_step(GenerateDocumentationStep)
docs_proofread_step = process_builder.add_step(ProofreadStep)  # Add new step here
docs_publish_step = process_builder.add_step(PublishDocumentationStep)

# Orchestrate the events
process_builder.on_input_event("Start").send_event_to(target=info_gathering_step)

info_gathering_step.on_function_result().send_event_to(
    target=docs_generation_step, function_name="generate_documentation", parameter_name="product_info"
)

docs_generation_step.on_event("documentation_generated").send_event_to(
    target=docs_proofread_step, parameter_name="docs"
)

docs_proofread_step.on_event("documentation_rejected").send_event_to(
    target=docs_generation_step,
    function_name="apply_suggestions",
    parameter_name="suggestions",
)

docs_proofread_step.on_event("documentation_approved").send_event_to(target=docs_publish_step)

Our updated process routing now does the following:

• When an external event with id = Start is sent to the process, this event and its associated data will be sent to the info_gathering_step.
• When the info_gathering_step finishes running, send the returned object to the docs_generation_step.
• When the docs_generation_step finishes running, send the generated docs to the docs_proofread_step.
• When the docs_proofread_step rejects our documentation and provides suggestions, send the suggestions back to the docs_generation_step.
• Finally, when the docs_proofread_step approves our documentation, send the returned object to the docs_publish_step. ::: zone-end

::: zone pivot="programming-language-java" ::: zone-end

Build and run the Process

Running our updated process shows the following output in the console:

::: zone pivot="programming-language-csharp"

GatherProductInfoStep:
        Gathering product information for product named Contoso GlowBrew
GenerateDocumentationStep:
        Generating documentation for provided productInfo...
ProofreadDocumentationAsync:
        Proofreading documentation...

        Grade: Fail
        Explanation: The proposed documentation has an overly casual tone and uses informal expressions that might not suit all customers. Additionally, some phrases may detract from the professionalism expected in customer-facing documentation. There are minor areas that could benefit from clarity and conciseness.
        Suggestions: Adjust the tone to be more professional and less casual; phrases like 'dazzling light show' and 'coffee performing' could be simplified.
                Remove informal phrases such as 'who knew coffee could be so... illuminating?'
                Consider editing out overly whimsical phrases like 'it's like a warm hug for your nose!' for a more straightforward description.
                Clarify the troubleshooting section for better customer understanding; avoid metaphorical language like 'secure that coffee cup when you realize Monday is still a thing.'
GenerateDocumentationStep:
        Rewriting documentation with provided suggestions...
ProofreadDocumentationAsync:
        Proofreading documentation...

        Grade: Fail
        Explanation: The documentation generally maintains a professional tone but contains minor phrasing issues that could be improved. There are no spelling or grammar mistakes noted, and it excludes any offensive language. However, the content could be more concise, and some phrases can be streamlined for clarity. Additionally, technical accuracy regarding troubleshooting solutions may require more details for the user's understanding. For example, clarifying how to 'reset the lighting settings through the designated app' would enhance user experience.
        Suggestions: Rephrase 'Join us as we elevate your coffee experience to new heights!' to make it more straightforward, such as 'Experience an elevated coffee journey with us.'
                In the 'Solution' section for the LED lights malfunction, add specific instructions on how to find and use the 'designated app' for resetting the lighting settings.
                Consider simplifying sentences such as 'Meet your new personal barista!' to be more straightforward, for example, 'Introducing your personal barista.'
                Ensure clarity in troubleshooting steps by elaborating on what a 'factory reset' entails.
GenerateDocumentationStep:
        Rewriting documentation with provided suggestions...
ProofreadDocumentationAsync:
        Proofreading documentation...

        Grade: Pass
        Explanation: The documentation presents a professional tone, contains no spelling or grammar mistakes, is free of offensive language, and is technically accurate regarding the product's features and troubleshooting guidance.
        Suggestions:
PublishDocumentationStep:
        Publishing product documentation:

# GlowBrew User Documentation

## Product Overview
Introducing GlowBrew-your new partner in coffee brewing that brings together advanced technology and aesthetic appeal. This innovative AI-driven coffee machine not only brews your favorite coffee but also features the industry's leading number of customizable LEDs and programmable light shows.

## Key Features

1. **Luminous Brew Technology**: Transform your morning routine with our customizable LED lights that synchronize with your brewing process, creating the perfect ambiance to start your day.

2. **AI Taste Assistant**: Our intelligent system learns your preferences over time, recommending exciting new brew combinations tailored to your unique taste.

3. **Gourmet Aroma Diffusion**: Experience an enhanced aroma with built-in aroma diffusers that elevate your coffee's scent profile, invigorating your senses before that all-important first sip.

## Troubleshooting

### Issue: LED Lights Malfunctioning

**Solution**:
- Begin by resetting the lighting settings via the designated app. Open the app, navigate to the settings menu, and select "Reset LED Lights."
- Ensure that all LED connections inside the GlowBrew are secure and properly connected.
- If issues persist, you may consider performing a factory reset. To do this, hold down the reset button located on the machine's back panel for 10 seconds while the device is powered on.

We hope you enjoy your GlowBrew experience and that it brings a delightful blend of flavor and brightness to your coffee moments!

::: zone-end

::: zone pivot="programming-language-python"

GatherProductInfoStep
         Gathering product information for Product Name: Contoso GlowBrew
GenerateDocumentationStep
         Generating documentation for provided product_info...
ProofreadStep
         Proofreading product documentation...

        Grade: Pass
        Explanation: The GlowBrew AI Coffee Machine User Guide meets all the required criteria for publishing. The document maintains a professional tone throughout, is free from spelling and grammatical errors, contains no offensive or inappropriate content, and appears to be technically accurate in its description of the product features and troubleshooting advice.
        Suggestions: 
PublishDocumentationStep
         Publishing product documentation:

# GlowBrew AI Coffee Machine User Guide

Welcome to the future of coffee making with the GlowBrew AI Coffee Machine! Step into a world where cutting-edge technology meets exquisite taste, creating a coffee experience like no other. Designed for coffee aficionados and tech enthusiasts alike, the GlowBrew promises not just a cup of coffee, but an adventure for your senses.

## Key Features

### Luminous Brew Technology
Illuminate your mornings with the GlowBrew's mesmerizing programmable LED light shows. With an unmatched number of LEDs, the GlowBrew can transform your kitchen ambiance to sync perfectly with each stage of the brewing process. Choose from a spectrum of colors and patterns to set the perfect mood, whether you're winding down with a rich decaf or kick-starting your day with a bold espresso.

### AI Taste Assistant
Expand your coffee horizons with the AI Taste Assistant, your personal barista that learns and evolves with your palate. Over time, GlowBrew adapts to your preferences, suggesting new and exciting brew combinations. Experience a variety of flavors, from single-origin specialties to intricate blend recipes, tailored to your unique taste.

### Gourmet Aroma Diffusion
Enhance your coffee experience with unrivaled aromatic pleasure. The GlowBrew's built-in aroma diffusers release a carefully calibrated scent profile that awakens your senses, heightening anticipation for your first sip. It's not just a coffee machine, it's an indulgent sensory journey.

## Troubleshooting

### LED Lights Malfunctioning
If you experience issues with your LED lights:

1. **Reset the LED Settings**: Use the GlowBrew app to navigate to the lighting settings and perform a reset.
2. **Check LED Connections**: Open the GlowBrew machine and ensure all LED wiring connections are secure.
3. **Perform a Factory Reset**: As a last resort, a full factory reset can resolve persistent issues. Follow the instructions in the user manual to perform this reset safely.

## Experience the Glow

With GlowBrew, every cup of coffee is an art form that combines luminous aesthetics, an intuitive learning AI, and the intoxicating allure of rich aromas. Make each morning magical and every break a celebration with the GlowBrew AI Coffee Machine. Brew brilliantly, taste innovatively, and glow endlessly.

For more support, explore our comprehensive FAQ section or contact our dedicated customer service team.

::: zone-end

::: zone pivot="programming-language-java" ::: zone-end

What's Next?

Our process is now reliably generating documentation that meets our defined standards. This is great, but before we publish our documentation publicly we really should require a human to review and approve. Let's do that next.

[!div class="nextstepaction"] Human-in-the-loop