Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History

issues

Folders and files

NameName
Last commit message
Last commit date

parent directory

..
001 About SECoP Issues.rst
001 About SECoP Issues.rst
 
 
002 Equipment ID in Describing Message.rst
002 Equipment ID in Describing Message.rst
 
 
003 Timestamp Format.rst
003 Timestamp Format.rst
 
 
004 The Timeout SEC Node Property.rst
004 The Timeout SEC Node Property.rst
 
 
005 Definition of the term Qualifier.rst
005 Definition of the term Qualifier.rst
 
 
006 Keep Alive.rst
006 Keep Alive.rst
 
 
007 Time Synchronization.rst
007 Time Synchronization.rst
 
 
008 Groups and Hierarchy.rst
008 Groups and Hierarchy.rst
 
 
009 Module Meaning.rst
009 Module Meaning.rst
 
 
010 Character set for Names.rst
010 Character set for Names.rst
 
 
011 Default parameters value and target.rst
011 Default parameters value and target.rst
 
 
012 JSON values vs documents.rst
012 JSON values vs documents.rst
 
 
013 Access Control.rst
013 Access Control.rst
 
 
014 Synchonisation of Hardware Modules on Different SEC Nodes.rst
014 Synchonisation of Hardware Modules on Different SEC Nodes.rst
 
 
015 Support for Start Stop Pause Shutdown Commands.rst
015 Support for Start Stop Pause Shutdown Commands.rst
 
 
016 wanted_target Parameter.rst
016 wanted_target Parameter.rst
 
 
017 Collect Use Cases for starting.rst
017 Collect Use Cases for starting.rst
 
 
018 Interface Classes.rst
018 Interface Classes.rst
 
 
019 Set SEC Node clock over SECoP.rst
019 Set SEC Node clock over SECoP.rst
 
 
020 PID tables.rst
020 PID tables.rst
 
 
021 Usage of JSON null.rst
021 Usage of JSON null.rst
 
 
022 Enable Module instead of Shutdown Command.rst
022 Enable Module instead of Shutdown Command.rst
 
 
023 Adjust Datatypes.rst
023 Adjust Datatypes.rst
 
 
024 Mix Commands within Parameters in the Description.rst
024 Mix Commands within Parameters in the Description.rst
 
 
025 Pong Format.rst
025 Pong Format.rst
 
 
026 More Module Meanings.rst
026 More Module Meanings.rst
 
 
027 Proposals for Interface Classes.rst
027 Proposals for Interface Classes.rst
 
 
028 Clarify buffering mechanism.rst
028 Clarify buffering mechanism.rst
 
 
029 New messages for buffering.rst
029 New messages for buffering.rst
 
 
030 Clarify Message parsing.rst
030 Clarify Message parsing.rst
 
 
031 Clarify timing requirements of status updates.rst
031 Clarify timing requirements of status updates.rst
 
 
032 Clarify specification using RFC-style definitions.rst
032 Clarify specification using RFC-style definitions.rst
 
 
033 Include section about security and access control.rst
033 Include section about security and access control.rst
 
 
034 Clarify do message.rst
034 Clarify do message.rst
 
 
035 Partial Structs.rst
035 Partial Structs.rst
 
 
036 Dynamic units.rst
036 Dynamic units.rst
 
 
037 Clarification of status.rst
037 Clarification of status.rst
 
 
038 Extension mechanisms.rst
038 Extension mechanisms.rst
 
 
039 Use cases.rst
039 Use cases.rst
 
 
040 Finalise Specification.rst
040 Finalise Specification.rst
 
 
041 Handling of JSON-numbers.rst
041 Handling of JSON-numbers.rst
 
 
042 Requirements of datatypes.rst
042 Requirements of datatypes.rst
 
 
043 Parameters and units.rst
043 Parameters and units.rst
 
 
044 Scaled integers.rst
044 Scaled integers.rst
 
 
045 Async error updates.rst
045 Async error updates.rst
 
 
046 remote logging.rst
046 remote logging.rst
 
 
047 Error classes.rst
047 Error classes.rst
 
 
048 mode parameter.rst
048 mode parameter.rst
 
 
049 Precision of Floating Point Values.rst
049 Precision of Floating Point Values.rst
 
 
050 Reserved Names.rst
050 Reserved Names.rst
 
 
051 No Restrictions on Datatype Nesting.rst
051 No Restrictions on Datatype Nesting.rst
 
 
052 Include Some Properties into Datatype.rst
052 Include Some Properties into Datatype.rst
 
 
053 Custom Status Values.rst
053 Custom Status Values.rst
 
 
054 Splitting _update_ into two Message Types.rst
054 Splitting _update_ into two Message Types.rst
 
 
055 Reformat Datatype description.rst
055 Reformat Datatype description.rst
 
 
056 Additional Busy States.rst
056 Additional Busy States.rst
 
 
058 use JSON key value for describe message.rst
058 use JSON key value for describe message.rst
 
 
059 set_mode and mode instead of some commands.rst
059 set_mode and mode instead of some commands.rst
 
 
060 enhancements to the documentation.rst
060 enhancements to the documentation.rst
 
 
061 new predefined property implementation.rst
061 new predefined property implementation.rst
 
 
062 naming convention for related parameters.rst
062 naming convention for related parameters.rst
 
 
063 enumeration of floating point values.rst
063 enumeration of floating point values.rst
 
 
064 reading multiple parameters simultaneously.rst
064 reading multiple parameters simultaneously.rst
 
 
065 handling of coupled sub modules.rst
065 handling of coupled sub modules.rst
 
 
066 force re-connect.rst
066 force re-connect.rst
 
 
067 pid control parameters.rst
067 pid control parameters.rst
 
 
068 transaction of multiple commands.rst
068 transaction of multiple commands.rst
 
 
069 optional structs by default.rst
069 optional structs by default.rst
 
 
070 message is a JSON object.rst
070 message is a JSON object.rst
 
 
071 accessing sub items of parameters.rst
071 accessing sub items of parameters.rst
 
 
072 features.rst
072 features.rst
 
 
073 HasLimits and HasOffset.rst
073 HasLimits and HasOffset.rst
 
 
074 Standardization of units.rst
074 Standardization of units.rst
 
 
075 New messages check and checked.rst
075 New messages check and checked.rst
 
 
076 Interface for Measurable hardware.rst
076 Interface for Measurable hardware.rst
 
 
077 predefined parameter name prefixes.rst
077 predefined parameter name prefixes.rst
 
 
078 Interacting Modules - use case power supply.rst
078 Interacting Modules - use case power supply.rst
 
 
079 hints for readonly access.rst
079 hints for readonly access.rst
 
 
080 issues with software ramp.rst
080 issues with software ramp.rst
 
 
081 dynamic descriptive data.rst
081 dynamic descriptive data.rst
 
 
082 Feature HasRamp.rst
082 Feature HasRamp.rst
 
 
README.rst
README.rst
 
 
makeissuelist.py
makeissuelist.py
 
 

README.rst

Note

SECoP Issues have been replaced by the RFC process, which is described in RFC 1.

If there is renewed interest in one of the remaining open issues, please migrate to an RFC before restarting discussion.

SECoP Issues

The idea behind SECoP Issues is to document properly what was proposed, what was discussed, what was decided and why it was decided.

An issue might take different states:

(u) unspecified

a vague idea, but no proposal written down yet

(p) proposed

A proposal should contain the motivation. As long as nobody else joins into a discussion, the state remains proposed

(d) under discussion

This state is kept until there is a decision taken.

(f) finalizing

This state is kept until the specification change is agreed.

( ) closed

After a decision the state is closed. The issue is not deleted, even if the decision was to not follow further the proposal. This is helpful if somebody later rises a similar issue. However, it should be possible to reopen an issue, if new arguments arise.

Remark:

At the meeting in Lund (13th June 2018), it was agreed not to follow the proposal of creating a new state "extensible" for an issue containing an extensible list. Instead, an new issue should be created, containing the added elements. A full actual list should be added each time.

Issues List

SECoP Issue 1: About SECoP Issues
SECoP Issue 2: Equipment ID in Describing Message
SECoP Issue 3: Timestamp Format
SECoP Issue 4: The Timeout SEC Node Property
SECoP Issue 5: Definition of the term 'Qualifier'
SECoP Issue 6: Keep Alive
SECoP Issue 7: Time Synchronization
SECoP Issue 8: Groups and Hierarchy
SECoP Issue 9: Module Meaning
SECoP Issue 10: Character set for Names
SECoP Issue 11: Default parameters 'value' and 'target'
SECoP Issue 12: JSON values vs documents
SECoP Issue 13: Access Control
u SECoP Issue 14: Synchonisation of Hardware Modules on Different SEC Nodes
SECoP Issue 15: Support for Start/Stop/Pause/Shutdown Commands
SECoP Issue 16: wanted_target Parameter
SECoP Issue 17: Collect Use Cases for 'starting'
d SECoP Issue 18: Interface Classes
SECoP Issue 19: Set SEC Node clock over SECoP
u SECoP Issue 20: PID tables
SECoP Issue 21: Usage of JSON null
u SECoP Issue 22: Enable Module instead of Shutdown Command
SECoP Issue 23: Adjust Datatypes
SECoP Issue 24: Mix Commands within Parameters in the Description
SECoP Issue 25: Pong Format
SECoP Issue 26: More Module Meanings
d SECoP Issue 27: Proposals for Interface Classes
SECoP Issue 28: Clarify buffering mechanism
SECoP Issue 29: New messages for buffering
SECoP Issue 30: Clarify Message parsing
SECoP Issue 31: Clarify timing requirements of status updates
SECoP Issue 32: Clarify specification using RFC-style definitions
SECoP Issue 33: Include section about security and access control
SECoP Issue 34: Clarify 'do' message
SECoP Issue 35: Partial Structs
SECoP Issue 36: Dynamic units
SECoP Issue 37: Clarification of status
SECoP Issue 38: Extension mechanisms
p SECoP Issue 39: Use cases
p SECoP Issue 40: Finalise Specification
SECoP Issue 41: Handling of JSON-numbers
SECoP Issue 42: Requirements of datatypes
SECoP Issue 43: Parameters and units
SECoP Issue 44: Scaled integers
SECoP Issue 45: Async error updates
SECoP Issue 46: remote logging
SECoP Issue 47: Error classes
SECoP Issue 48: mode parameter
SECoP Issue 49: Precision of Floating Point Values
SECoP Issue 50: Reserved Names
SECoP Issue 51: No Restrictions on Datatype Nesting
SECoP Issue 52: Include Some Properties into Datatype
SECoP Issue 53: Custom Status Values
SECoP Issue 54: Splitting _update_ into two Message Types
SECoP Issue 55: Reformat Datatype description
SECoP Issue 56: Additional Busy States
SECoP Issue 58: use JSON key, value for describe message
SECoP Issue 59: set_mode and mode instead of some commands
u SECoP Issue 60: enhancements to the documentation
SECoP Issue 61: new predefined property implementation
u SECoP Issue 62: naming convention for related parameters
SECoP Issue 63: enumeration of floating point values
SECoP Issue 64: reading multiple parameters simultaneously
SECoP Issue 65: handling of coupled (sub)modules
SECoP Issue 66: force re-connect
f SECoP Issue 67: pid control parameters
SECoP Issue 68: transaction of multiple commands
f SECoP Issue 69: optional structs by default
u SECoP Issue 70: message is a JSON object
SECoP Issue 71: accessing sub items of parameters
SECoP Issue 72: features
p SECoP Issue 73: HasLimits and HasOffset
u SECoP Issue 74: Standardization of units
p SECoP Issue 75: New messages check and checked
p SECoP Issue 76: Interface for Measurable hardware
p SECoP Issue 77: predefined parameter name prefixes
p SECoP Issue 78: Interacting Modules - use case power supply
SECoP Issue 79: hints for readonly access
p SECoP Issue 80: issues with software ramp
p SECoP Issue 81: dynamic descriptive data
p SECoP Issue 82: Feature HasRamp