Skip to content

Not able to define behaviour for overloaded functions with different parameters. #141

@AndreasInpact

Description

@AndreasInpact

We recently upated the version of Delphi-Mocks we where using and with this version it looks like we can not define differen behaviour for overloaded functions.

  IMockIntf = interface(IInvokable)
    ['{E473945B-D350-4535-A981-B66A5B58DA21}']
    function Test(const Arg1: string): TArray<string>; overload;
    function Test(const Arg1, Arg2: string): TArray<string>; overload;
    function Test(const Arg1, Arg2, Arg3: string): TArray<string>; overload;
  end;

Given this interface it was possible (and needed) to define a return value for alle 3 functions separatly.

  FMock := TMock<IMockIntf>.Create;

  FMock.Setup.WillReturn('Test1').When.Test(It0.IsAny<string>);
  FMock.Setup.WillReturn('Test2').When.Test(It0.IsAny<string>, It1.IsAny<string>);
  FMock.Setup.WillReturn('Test3').When.Test(It0.IsAny<string>, It1.IsAny<string>, It3.IsAny<string>);

And than test the behaviour

procedure TMyTestObject.Test1;
begin
  var x := FMock.Instance.Test('A');
  Assert.AreEqual('Test1', x);
end;

procedure TMyTestObject.Test2;
begin
  var x := FMock.Instance.Test('A', 'B');
  Assert.AreEqual('Test2', x);
end;

procedure TMyTestObject.Test3;
begin
  var x := FMock.Instance.Test('A', 'B', 'C');
  Assert.AreEqual('Test3', x);
end;

Unfortenatly with the latest version this is not working anymore. I looks like the Mock sees the Test functions as one and will not allow this:

EMockSetupException with message '[IMockIntf] already defines Will Return When for method [Test]'

If I use AllowRedefineBehaviorDefinitions := True I can define the behaviour, but than the function with 2 parameters returns the behaviour with 3 parameter 'Test3' and the function with 3 parameter raises an Access violation at address 00000000.

I used the latest version in combination with Delphi 11.3.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions