Unable to download bug on Safari

[Ahmad-S792]

Steps to Reproduce

1. Go to https://commitmono.com
2. Go to 'Customize'
3. Click on Download custom for dev

Expected Results

It should download without issue.

Actual Result

I get error and nothing gets logged in Web Console (Inspector) as well.

Just raising so this can be fixed.

If you need any help from WebKit side - please don't hesitate to raise bug on bugs.webkit.org.

Thanks!

[karlcow]

So indeed Firefox, Chrome OK
Safari not ok.

The link is a button…

<button class="button_link safari"
        onclick="downloadFont('dev', this)"
        tabindex="0"
        contenteditable="false">
    Download custom for dev
</button>

Which is calling downloadFont

{
    // console.log("downloadFont")

    // detect safari
    const userAgentString = navigator.userAgent || "."
    let usingChrome = userAgentString.indexOf("Chrome") > -1 || false
    let usingSafari = userAgentString.indexOf("Safari") > -1 || false
    if (usingChrome && usingSafari) usingSafari = false

    // block download if from Safari since zip is corrupted
    if (usingSafari) {
        button.classList.remove("loaded", "error", "safari")
        button.classList.add("loading")
        setTimeout(() => {
            button.classList.remove("loading")
            button.classList.add("safari")
        }, 500)
    } else {
        if (!downloadStarted) {
            downloadStarted = true
            button.classList.remove("loaded", "error", "safari")
            button.classList.add("loading")

   // cut for brevity

            Promise.all(Object.values(allSettings).map((settings) => makeCustomFont(settings)))
                .then((resolve) => getZipFileBlob(kindOfDownload, resolve))
                .then((resolve) => initializeDownload(button, resolve))
                .catch((error) => catchError(button, error))
        }
    }
}

The reason in the comments for blocking Safari seems to be because the zip is corrupted.

    // block download if from Safari since zip is corrupted
    if (usingSafari) {
        button.classList.remove("loaded", "error", "safari")
        button.classList.add("loading")
        setTimeout(() => {
            button.classList.remove("loading")
            button.classList.add("safari")
        }, 500)

With a UA override to be chrome on Safari, for example, I get the confirm download window.

It is downloading locally the zip file after choosing where I want to save it.
It unzips without issues.

Inside the folder.

% ls -a1 ~/Downloads/CommitMonoV143
CommitMono-400-Italic.otf
CommitMono-400-Regular.otf
CommitMono-700-Italic.otf
CommitMono-700-Regular.otf
custom-settings.json
installation.txt
license.txt

So maybe there was a reason in the past which is not valid anymore. And the UA sniffing could be removed.

commit-mono/src/js/download_wizard.js

Lines 30 to 37 in 696c044

	if (usingSafari) {
	button.classList.remove("loaded", "error", "safari")
	button.classList.add("loading")
	setTimeout(() => {
	button.classList.remove("loading")
	button.classList.add("safari")
	}, 500)
	} else {

[karlcow]

This was created in #19 to solve probably #17

[eigilnikolajsen]

I should have a look at this again, I should be able to get the ZIP on Safari to work.

[karlcow]

If you identify new troubles @eigilnikolajsen do not hesitate to contact me.

[fpigeonjr]

confirmed on Orion (Version 0.99.130.2-beta (WebKit 621.1.2.111.4))

[brentfulgham]

Any updates on this? It's been a year since we last checked in. Testing today, it appears to still block Safari.