Firefox for Android doesn't deliver every push notifications

[way2datta]

Thanks for the library. It is working well for Chrome/Firefox for MAC/Windows.
Also, working well with Edge for Windows and Android Chrome.

However, it is giving me a problem when it comes to Android FireFox.

I can subscribe and unsubscribe from Android Firefox. But when a message is sent to the client on Android Firefox below error is thrown:

local.WARNING: Notification failed to sent for subscription 
https://updates.push.services.mozilla.com/wpush/v2/gAAAAABdrtWvpZ_Cb5z45s6s6Sio_y6twMDdwlG4JDYP4qCHfyByM6khVgqmaBODaDTCLAGrN3gQOgUoHfI_Dz8zZ8Lp3_uE-VSvNTZXWD1Ys7_-sUd8prpRpug5tFyorg8TTCpEHuhJG8ygUUsEcQzMM__RadRsHFvdQkdUnrY7vQ6DUbG_zKA: 
Client error: `POST https://updates.push.services.mozilla.com/wpush/v2/gAAAAABdrtWvpZ_Cb5z45s6s6Sio_y6twMDdwlG4JDYP4qCHfyByM6khVgqmaBODaDTCLAGrN3gQOgUoHfI_Dz8zZ8Lp3_uE-VSvNTZXWD1Ys7_-sUd8prpRpug5tFyorg8TTCpEHuhJG8ygUUsEcQzMM__RadRsHFvdQkdUnrY7vQ6DUbG_zKA` 
resulted in a `410 Gone` response:

{"code": 410, "errno": 999, "error": "",
 "more_info": "http://autopush.readthedocs.io/en/latest/http.html#error-codes",  (truncated...)

[atymic]

Are you still having an issue?

[oele-dev]

I still have this issue

[joantp]

I still have this issue

So do I. Any news, about that?

[sebsobseb]

Same here

[nyneplus]

Dito
Could it be related to this

Perhaps some where we can add:
$webpush->setAutomaticPadding(2847); $webpush->sendNotification(...)

[maciek-szn]

I don't know if it's related, but I'm getting version 1 of Mozilla webpush service endpoint (so https://updates.push.services.mozilla.com/wpush/v1/...), instead of version 2. And yes, notifications are not delivered, however there are no errors.

[gbr161]

Hi, im facing this issue too.
I've tried to remote debug firefox on my phone to catch errors but there are none, checked laravel logs - same story.
Im getting the v1 endpoint in database as @maciek-szn.
Notifications work in every other browser except firefox mobile.
Anyone knows what the problem is?

[goaround]

I run into the same issue. It's explained here: SherClockHolmes/webpush-go#23 (comment)

It's possible to set the automatic Padding to 3052 bytes in WebPush: https://github.com/web-push-libs/web-push-php#how-can-i-disable-or-customize-automatic-padding

It could be added here:

webpush/src/WebPushServiceProvider.php

Line 33 in c8778df

return (new WebPush(

But I think an option in the config to enable it, would be better.

Another automatic way would be to check if the endpoints is v1: https://updates.push.services.mozilla.com/wpush/v1/... and then set automatic padding to 3052 bytes or if not 4078 bytes here:

webpush/src/WebPushChannel.php

Line 55 in 2272542

$this->webPush->queueNotification(new Subscription(

[imrodrigoalves]

I think I've something here guys. Maybe you can make use of it too.

Hope it helps.

#176 (comment)

[markusramsak]

I tested in Firefox on my Android phone and got the following results:

$webPush->setAutomaticPadding(2820); // still works
$webPush->setAutomaticPadding(2821); // doesn't work anymore (413 Payload Too Large)

[joostdebruijn]

The automatic padding is now (with v10.1.0) configurable with WEBPUSH_AUTOMATIC_PADDING. By default it follows the default value from web-push-php, which is Encryption::MAX_COMPATIBILITY_PAYLOAD_LENGTH (2820 bytes). So that should solve this issue and it allows customizing for who want to configure something else.