Skip to content

When using singleton types assertEquals does not work but == does  #770

@hmf

Description

@hmf

Using veersion 3.4.2-RC1.

I have the following definitions that implement a map version of an HList:

sealed trait IMap:
case object IEmpT extends IMap
case class ICons[K, V, T <: IMap](key: K, value: V, tail: T) extends IMap

The following non-commented code compiles in Scala 3 (3.4.2-RC1):

    val ff1b: ICons["5", 5, IEmpT] = ICons("5", 5, IEmpT)
    summon[ff1b.type <:< ICons["5", 5,IEmpT]]
    // summon[ICons["5", 5,IEmpT] =:= ff1b.type] // fails
    // summon[ICons["5", 5,IEmpT] <:< ff1b.type] // fails

The commented code above fails. I can compare the values with == without any problem as shown below:

    assert(ICons("5", 5,IEmpT) == ff1b) // Ok
    assert(ff1b == ICons("5", 5,IEmpT)) // Ok
    assert(ff1b.isInstanceOf[ICons[String, Int, IEmpT]])

However the following fails to compile with errors shown at the end:

    assertEquals(ICons("5", 5,IEmpT), ff1b)
    assertEquals(ff1b, ICons("5", 5,IEmpT))

Because == works, I would assume that the assertEquals above should also work, but it do not. Looking at this code it seems it should work. Indeed, when I don't use singleton types, it does. However ComparePriority1 and ComparePriority2 don't seem to be working as expected.

Is this expected?

TIA

[error] 608 |    assertEquals(ICons("5", 5,IEmpT), ff1b)
[error]     |    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
[error]     |Can't compare these two types:
[error]     |  First type:  icollection.IMap.ICons[String, Int, icollection.IMap.IEmpT.type]
[error]     |  Second type: icollection.IMap.ICons[("5" : String), (5 : Int), icollection.IMap.IEmpT]
[error]     |Possible ways to fix this error:
[error]     |  Alternative 1: provide an implicit instance for Compare[icollection.IMap.ICons[String, Int, icollection.IMap.IEmpT.type], icollection.IMap.ICons[("5" : String), (5 : Int), icollection.IMap.IEmpT]]
[error]     |  Alternative 2: upcast either type into `Any` or a shared supertype.
[error]     |I found:
[error]     |
[error]     |    munit.Compare.compareSubtypeWithSupertype[
[error]     |      icollection.IMap.ICons[String, Int, icollection.IMap.IEmpT.type],
[error]     |      icollection.IMap.ICons[("5" : String), (5 : Int), icollection.IMap.IEmpT]](
[error]     |      /* missing */
[error]     |        summon[icollection.IMap.ICons[String, Int, icollection.IMap.IEmpT.type] <:<
[error]     |          icollection.IMap.ICons[("5" : String), (5 : Int), icollection.IMap.IEmpT]]
[error]     |      )
[error]     |
[error]     |But no implicit values were found that match type icollection.IMap.ICons[String, Int, icollection.IMap.IEmpT.type] <:<
[error]     |  icollection.IMap.ICons[("5" : String), (5 : Int), icollection.IMap.IEmpT].
[error] -- [E172] Type Error: /home/hmf/VSCodeProjects/sploty/meta/test/src/icollection/IMapSpec.scala:609:16 
[error] 609 |    assertEquals(ff1b, ICons("5", 5,IEmpT))
[error]     |    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
[error]     |Can't compare these two types:
[error]     |  First type:  icollection.IMap.ICons[("5" : String), (5 : Int), icollection.IMap.IEmpT]
[error]     |  Second type: icollection.IMap.ICons[String, Int, icollection.IMap.IEmpT.type]
[error]     |Possible ways to fix this error:
[error]     |  Alternative 1: provide an implicit instance for Compare[icollection.IMap.ICons[("5" : String), (5 : Int), icollection.IMap.IEmpT], icollection.IMap.ICons[String, Int, icollection.IMap.IEmpT.type]]
[error]     |  Alternative 2: upcast either type into `Any` or a shared supertype.
[error]     |I found:
[error]     |
[error]     |    munit.Compare.compareSubtypeWithSupertype[
[error]     |      icollection.IMap.ICons[("5" : String), (5 : Int), icollection.IMap.IEmpT],
[error]     |      icollection.IMap.ICons[String, Int, icollection.IMap.IEmpT.type]](
[error]     |      /* missing */
[error]     |        summon[
[error]     |          icollection.IMap.ICons[("5" : String), (5 : Int), icollection.IMap.IEmpT]
[error]     |          <:< icollection.IMap.ICons[String, Int, icollection.IMap.IEmpT.type]]
[error]     |    )
[error]     |
[error]     |But no implicit values were found that match type icollection.IMap.ICons[("5" : String), (5 : Int), icollection.IMap.IEmpT] <:<
[error]     |  icollection.IMap.ICons[String, Int, icollection.IMap.IEmpT.type].
[warn] -- Warning: /home/hmf/VSCodeProjects/sploty/meta/test/src/icollection/IMapSpec.scala:882:19 

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions