From 7265b142dcce04696aaae67e310411f96e2602d9 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: zackbatist Date: Fri, 31 Jan 2025 11:56:07 -0500 Subject: [PATCH] Built site for gh-pages --- .nojekyll | 2 +- context.html | 2 +- ethics-protocol.pdf | Bin 51457 -> 51470 bytes research-protocol.pdf | Bin 70343 -> 70340 bytes search.json | 2 +- sitemap.xml | 2 +- 6 files changed, 4 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/.nojekyll b/.nojekyll index 46f57e4..314d8ed 100644 --- a/.nojekyll +++ b/.nojekyll @@ -1 +1 @@ -5f21bac9 \ No newline at end of file +306f74d9 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/context.html b/context.html index f1743d3..1539015 100644 --- a/context.html +++ b/context.html @@ -221,7 +221,7 @@

Context

I am Zack Batist — a postdoctoral researcher at McGill University, in the School of Global and Public Health’s Department of Epidemiology, Biostatistics and Occupuational Health. I’m working with David Buckeridge, who leads the Covid-19 Immunity Task Force (CITF) Databank, to investigate data sharing in epidemiological research — with an emphasis on the practical and situated experiences involved in data sharing.

The CITF is a “data harmonization” initiative, which entails coordinating a systematic effort to align the information contained in datasets collected by distributed teams of epidemiologists. These efforts to integrate the records collected during various discrete studies are motivated by a desire to establish larger integrated datasets bearing greater statistical power and that facilitate comparison across cohorts. However, epidemiologists must reckon with the diversity of minor variations in data collection procedures, as well as ethico-legal concerns relating to the sharing of individual health records pertaining to human research subjects across numerous institutional and regional jurisdictions.

As a scholar of scientific practice, with a primary interest in data-sharing and the formation of information commons, data harmonization represents a fascinating mechanism through which scientists derive technical, administrative, social and epistemic frameworks to enhance the value of their collective endeavours in response to disciplinary needs, warrants, desires and expectations. This study therefore articulates the motivations for doing data harmonization, identifies how value is ascertained, and describes the strategies employed to achieve the desired goals — including perceived and actual challenges, setbacks, opportunities, realizations, and lessons learned.

-

This relates to my previous work that (a) explores tensions that arise when attempting to establish information commons in archaeology, specifically relating to inability to cope with a superficial perception of data’s stability an intuitive understanding of their situated nature; and that (b) investigates how the open science movement attempts (and fails) to reshape practices relating to data sharing, integration and reuse. I continue in my approach that frames data-sharing — whether it occurs in relatively “closed” curcumstances between close colleagues, or as mediated by open data platforms among strangers — as comprising a series of collaborative commitments that govern who may contribute to and obtain value from the information commons, and in what ways.

+

This relates to my previous work that (a) explores tensions that arise when attempting to establish information commons in archaeology, specifically relating to inability to cope with a superficial perception of data’s stability and an intuitive understanding of their situated nature; and that (b) investigates how the open science movement attempts (and fails) to reshape practices relating to data sharing, integration and reuse. I continue in my approach that frames data-sharing — whether it occurs in relatively “closed” curcumstances between close colleagues, or as mediated by open data platforms among strangers — as comprising a series of collaborative commitments that govern who may contribute to and obtain value from the information commons, and in what ways.

diff --git a/ethics-protocol.pdf b/ethics-protocol.pdf index ba4f6ef9e4647f4c085810e4144c91a60d589785..59a630546440758f8af29442be06534c95c54e4c 100644 GIT binary patch delta 6949 zcmaiZRZyG(vn&J%ES|+3!r~rmk>Kv`?wa5Z9~NZMu)$q}1cGaD5AF`Z9fAc2cJiNx zQ}^8aaNqi2rlxADr>kcsBnc@#38}hN9^e)cL3j6Xvo?1|_gOYhGIb2&#P8pD!uMSz zmX33t4nfm4#GQ8@{aedlv7l0_UJ!WDl)D#>O{jK9cRL|4>)FG~J!V@|SE>a{K*~zf3pavqAUf{mQ2y zH4C|5AA~JxDHwtWLM0Z8NV$_3IbfRtkqdSr0M%+YM$G5Xn0-f=dm#&o=&dq zEn%lD7+j zVtA(y{(*BV3L^5rKPXZG5{^uG^UkwgvF*jfhvB4>vynj$=|YE+NTA2Fv)t9)^Zov+ z$+50Sj+J5XYaLz#{e!kC1v8>jveQplWir^@n@oo0!lI&RS2PA@LH7@V0S~@GqU3El z2ZJSNZp zrE!YaFzX6TyK6T}U@(b<@q@MZSi(Wo3*CjHcFk7x&fKv(y|%ZbU)~I=nsT{a@fav`c|nRsOi6`* zSCR)-9D2lXBhIhz{q32O!j_CNz>}qnbB#X1>jPHxh;<;xAHPpCPek?Xs6#$-bH9v^ z$L3b;J8CxeywrMjeAUTP)YNO8^Uj1rr;2$@h@%Te4e4*kD!yGjdSvoa=}Y%)1aPeD zRxFHp>FTC~!ZyEk5cY1HlQ64Kl9WWsO1=dwOeSs<3>D{=vmCk7eI)MM*e@#^aJbS4 zZ=y~9)~OmMvW-b&#viU{pPVbZ7sHfTUUA49HRHDIdWtvEj||)FNvuN-a-@_}*5E!? zFyO@!)HEaTGVJt`a$N9=I;yu%{YWmP;0@!eZjCsxYI0?9ciFZ4LKKUEJi14*LNq>z zIBAjCw>)ujYs@XiJZSJbIeyP2Rv)?&7n<(?IuBBu_>f@ETlB#lqck<=9|-vdC`oF% zif~pHF2pLhi3$blgvmkwhWyb0e7~A%HmE&kC3&OrbYSf?&#)+HPf>D$*ZHXA*6p0b z?BIA5{#8W?;QwE$@nr?J!ig`v@kHR4rSaO-N*)g_0uoPCZ$DzyGg@KEQf3|??n-%i z+t9#IQc4q295XRJbphgU3s~SSM0;uO5L{Hx%B=GGv%Fzs-9K!S!5)RD&Oax2`J!!z zE#AD8+WWn>;q5Bb##I8<25@Hj&J*iGhl^_8bGZ&392Oo=4F zA36F{{QTKk+qP&%qO3}v(tm9ga(eW#ht-rlKDRMFHnM$FFAST8Ue#X|iOU0_Eyxfq zSp##G(BFj0J%&5zU;Hy(zjvaHSr)%0`37k>qq}7jixqQ3 zD&UQ_i525kBi+Olh|0mheJ{_1W~;hcwm|JuG9-nrs$4)qI~f}uP-2LCStehd5>@pp zosinc0W3^+rbClE^IEl<5Aq3^**ZbDl_N%+2NkgRkaoat$9;zKB--uLNWi1`N7B8c zi9Rz!=@IFD6!vNItMw%$TlQ&8tMvozWZ+sB62$o=_G+C{qPP>%#C+Z@5`*6U$&5bC zx3;fy&;_`E^FXvhBt8-Ak%21+Zq0PQ9m_grF8$D(Fcml++c9;7);_%>y=WjHa({%t zh&t$gujFR-uFg>^SGEf9HxO_94YY^HzE8W^26CHg_w`_Uj=R_6e4$r{jsP1DD}3 zfYSzQ(ZPWIZV)LPD@WhQ0pdMR;0hW-0MGv#6E)?JVVs!l`?`0F_8HVlDNDMCzZT9j?iLK?nd2HmeyF!)KAIF!&tKeb2S6Otg$U*iG;%Ga2x96 z-~I%3Y0Y%bl!iKuJb{AVyn!guy>Zi(gfzg)@!rt<()R2@w^$Bd z@Q!~b)W4}G|4YeWWN;ufTIKK!_C8EHoNfMjD|}f}0rob&uqiYAGt`iM()In@;hFm2 zA5|Ek2G7T*upnIBGrqm6fl(6$(iS07t?rGr9KEcSKLZR>vgR$*J}+=yzEX=v#387& zHM;c&tN*qX@K8-%RE!I3cO1-xx?h^_5RpGxx$(dWwT1pK+o9I&(EG154=f%h#B|Eo zYjnu-U#4R{$&?MeJe}xxc^cKTB%gyC$^6p9Ucc{TIAmg~2rNzx+lh=Vof7|A4uvlP= z?14@Uv3*l+A$^_+tQ&WX)S`Ec#18l8fO>4_!3NT%6aVn3l2t=h8+ko8O@Ftu(-B z06r6W5IMQJO?awt#Awf=Dhpc2;O@-w?!YHlQws>XfxOxi7HX$NYG~>3v}kY(cNuI1 z_PEkg(<&>@6h6)@eJvZ}X(g;v^s8m~YP+#fM)w|VLLSVr-)p?2eSHvw@MKj$jf|4lP|S$z>@pbM;ez#(H7+ux@gPP_ z=sKha0Y41FOeeP)AHC0nTfxdIO}S?cP*X80;;Nd##D0^Q=d1=3Qa8u@P&#hK?96M# zg4|GhQY>)7K`>AT;%&EQY@kB3j?!dojVfpX1`EUP?MI1uG6AwpCg-@4&Q7_F8_m=}0MT+}I^!Qx;dFXXL@v0A z9x!YXYH3FyL6O1N2ND>WUVhV;q&I^463Di+Gx>?&pEjj0l`?u4>tGk)k*Mc~ z$=J&;W`-b3#8pnS%8N5^65^XoxsDWU4V~hg;}#ft3X*r2bR^i$xIT3VSPBV4ovTs< zYf+-dlsaMwX^dT3DhAfgb&m$bQn-Tcl7O=HDYOb4dk3S3B@TH=v7w%E46{;s_cE$i zDMcUaL~pB=*FWm5|A%@ptTA7I(yXW^bI)FG0D=`qGOGfq1-$bW5-*5+?4GgzGo{Y|K_4v~>fH6o&43lR6&Y~g z#`iA6KIJ!Q4|Kb3$*j_!omegmF0FfihtSic6Tr04hH7q)Z?7>CLcugKDLc&tn4GCO zXEU~~wwycf%t1t;RMt0d-^kEQ(80FH=nTq`Zw3kyqj^O>)4S?GrWs5QrOe6k2-on& z*;K!Tlb?Yxx6wI%LX3p!+kkK~25?*%IkLm`l@dMa>H2Y>nT1WDh0)vQK_%ulNf&+M z7$#6qNIT^8BBtdd#S?pg3f&JLU7E*d?Cd)#Vv@3NM%XNGOJE- z>R>-z4)d??JNzeMQV{aFlEqL!6}V8nN6%8t;1zOlq{zF^Mrp_e5CBuztRUPxx)<90 zJKir^1(%LD78QT`6;Y%srCLG7H8MN;M?AZ7;w5Y=lD|+KtNcu<_Fu#pgJ@=3D2Wlo zdgb_Lm!-Os+FW0J5JMGuZ9e`&M5H;eg{*=EQhJ>{8oIEDSWq_*^><0Cr4hA#3s7)( zcBnx^P= zN|_TTBoHttF2NE^+|48%`Woqnz+fBFMlikmEEXe128oM;UQ}5Y&DI-kn)tAe@m@IR zEXM3BD2KgC=`Vt41Yayqgx>ZrGAL93FX8EwH`7Mox?%>CEg+-|=@eR*LaYLp05_w0 zLJ@#Vh|rT;x^3IleZi6A-2RPvDwn&#=E*hYUTGB8{yy@&&tx`j#6C$+ zwNT?9@H&%5QM0A)dUBD#jP~)tU4(eGjAAgx8+Zv}mZr?tc?^&H zh1*FnPB^m#pm7w{mGTvaR~W!d@Ip_A;9c31xgdMpbXCL35tCbc0u)~4QpxPrGtL}7 zI(Ak@UTY>St8^968&zb^W44J*2jgSlkQSli z>@45yMDuM%GdfksisMHoz=%U+OMg4G5a;gfQu{XmKw|b@?#Ri3g-6bL|CT;$JSBSC zMd{Fkv`E<6Ouz8cvBh*(UXfCJu>NvU)JMGz!Q_aZWK|OW1s6S%5vDAYx(ab?L!^(e zkH6M19XtlZl&>m7Nex!bdcD0}$DTT0o`u?pb5(8YJcNG^)b-C5iKep;U*%q!uu$6# zYKl(*iY>Eh&sX%k^N-wrskckMcr@rTey;2ifuM|Q&|FKF@sK1JKKI*UFLGS^wsc^k zp+IoQ^vW?$O%mOkmHI{ZsHzAoAoqhMv9I{4UH=HN4V^o&g8_%n##jqXrHpARpG#{{ z%*u40Yjn;d>}FUG1Wy9ot@KbT{Er{p{J7YFnC|gsi&ar3*^$~N_vk&Xn~0_Fg)sq@ z@{#(MsOvKyZs`3MYxzFb+Aba`-&B9?UTGka%&aQ8syHn7qtyi~O_a`Mo|3ftxxcs6 z`PgB5643%n%X-GD^oAWmP;ce-ZN_!lqP=){Yi*bO;?DFtOf3ENH1lofR(>k`&7Oh* zKchf9u+u9hko--vwmFJ_(*tKUum%k_z;v)v&vVf z7eBYZoS%Crd`3GFNjDv{k*xpSK+npGTlAsslrQWqfz5TUWML4L+cWKFbX)ByUESLg z;a5n%c=i=q>tPp4k$yHUMeFFChKtG*Zf;zlV(;9M#ti=bnag!uwb5rUbhxLQJ2GR&)NvtIM z%xo^44wnkG7#Xw;DL1A@6DxY#$~L&hv$O-P+FoYnyJ=QB8$B5L;!}pkJ;v!2k%FXM zit1dNk~%VeA<@(K_c_$6Wh8Gk6wG$&l>6qas>^$74(pCQ;!&*XqGw`%(wE|9v|^r> zLwxbXca$uxj0-9)blpzQpWm>6t8`KV`c60#9oC6eV&(1bnfyknTx>YxN~zNN5Bs~N zrDG$12z7}|7{f1#EqrmsP3ssNr++Q@)-)T$Uxju!Pvuqf`+ZWHS2|`fzXE^n7wfAB z->RYnmPTh_hOba-*9s}z9BZr`H&PmE5k||%tuBN^H1tahhl`6pt$zDNbZj68)c7{H zZ2$gq;;kh_oYB`D;BK+ORr7JLk6D@JP9g>AAS+4c6$p25DStv^**vHOtMeTn-Ol7;8C9W)UR+T9I#})IlR*)7h?0mg&X-nn zn<|3G@~#D|kh<~-eHOd;Hz!p;6XG=d>J{*42FLf^?D zOGsKq417|V9OhIM)1V7RCViWa5$~WD47Na1Xgv!imQF=Mk7(u`atDW?utrka7!nBC zOX!5xWR)S#%Mwf3!Sy6EBM_~LseOa9wP+S4nL;bYBVod5u{*e8&gn>$Hl=-CZ=+fI zJjMCnr?3ZWIrRX-;Vc<;i4g!U1|9b`>9f-#t`r)|RFvoSq0ux!f+r#kVOd1%heY+V zl;#N9&ccx@2i##7C$R;(2D=P_A@}fBhEhAuytn!=IW&WK-_eZz{JD#JCI2f_wPrZE13OkZX{hQ*N%{h;|9g?bfwT_D#+o)QcUbYwdMQL zOTRzqoek`1F0N0Bv}+=b*>z_Mb_Qs|T6F3r7Wv)W&p6mLZB#c!%@U4Sfc|;Av zk^My2e(t7buMKZWu8#y2p4-pd-;Ylr+q)P99h#?%jOgDZ0Bs_SNdjkNoqpR&D)ID?OWoA)=gzRiNSo*`U3cj0t&Xq&L9tnagYW$>aHh zAd~1TMFOk$g{w=t5p;o@HJof~fNNRA(wkTJ9zTRcb9X@_*fxb%q3rrCHi^$DEx$oM zF9GU1s(McoH4T6&3kK6CCz(V8oRT`D>3;oHLxhzCS??PY2RHsHiM9=hR-s87l^{uS%EGog_8yg)W0XWho9PBdg?0@t6=A7yS zkjwkHl{1--M6|eC;Y`zw>7kReU)yX{x-kqE$CS9TAyZ9>MR=Wr>di(Bu=P+z>7c1PmcVlf&w;To;!X|oUXDK>X(WZ(W0^jb&s|x}$S>8dY z!wIB2YkhuIPe+@^Fok~Sq6^w@q19~N`KXwZcD?M>E#Ttc`U5KBbHP2^ZSSJ8-vaDD z`e+3OC{33h7jfOv#93q`4%BZrdz`Mh>N=(vaRj+!kPEhhp+f1G>KQq33?Mf;Mj{n;V{X4cJQl9IMurd4zv zJ$Vg6&*It^lomhqzXyQ3Ki8$$2zy+q%QtwTKNdjU!)LP8n zbnGJKf|D^K^vlszx+)iUhmRo~`(njS+G%LV#=q)^knhc-Zykzf!f^6&GFaHw=!e>u8aKL!7*O8u{D2Fo9M-6O2N7sLrf{xo>k0Gk9CrK^yVw-AGkP^oa-W1r&+Rktv zZ?##-+O85fCvBWnVMSh&sKIAp5x)jWsk5SBP>Gv%P4iFQ3-D3Bv~U~kt#b`LKEFO5n&CIE} zC|K0Qn@=*Qi%|6D8>4^sj15+a3YCkBATIMdNYOh8fx3P;sPl1&J~kReK1lw|LV-tv zahZ>Ro{yH4N34*C|1*y~iH6LLn&>j`l|~+Tng;1zH)2`hYi%{0IW?pPHPolcS6GwC z&XXtrflwi24O1|xq^@!MIrWC1Hz}2U3TNN&&ha|<`=eh zE&aeZ-nXcx1{iLOCA`cbxRutR$Ic+7599UoJ9~zXMjsOD8+ZRmI!c^z)O+nbYdUIB yQq}+2WfFH($N}p4cGq%#;T%!FH~oK>-+wai^pRv zMmn<6;)s^-%>fo<($i(r0Geu#s-N&Xlhzr`rfuEqq;plbKS)9Ufyb+d&s=1=0R2aym9xcg6_I|-c_}0KElm~5$~_Y&7e1*tB2EXl@uw7d7bp6swG&go}>#1O7kXuK%9rXx}Np+ zdG*-8jC+np?wgDT)Spn~hHgM7iW)KTV7Wp1EO_TU_}fOtAE}F;H(&*&i6>*aEAZ-~ zo0lLaFQ{bP6{TNlUUD0d-t#L@^`@LhO{AX*OlSRzlpc1_DKZbG;{1q!or`s=8+@-X z>uNm(5zm{kZ)$gDyO$nLzFj$8a$}mD7Cpp&gvd=C_-cLWXzp8Yv-N*2sRJn?K9KzN z8DyV+7Y5Ks8`_08Xi>nynw$V(xVt7ZETWk*>J9ymQ`y9F3K#NXxy$9r6?JB6we^62 zr)>dPH&;^GA?Gg4f}c0jbot9*Z^dig@YTYjG#a0|OCNJQh$QaT&45`ZL>TSjNclIs z;FbIYjVvzJ`3V-{M&S65c|mU!XiERhgV49XqdN`32^557E+9>VBw<*})s_P@%ndGn zi!CVd$C17sdAP7^Zb)0{WPd93F57h7@tHM^eu%!f5FM}w|3`QR_SmRtu(|PWxXa^C zU#3H=@gx4xXrCQ7Nd((CgZD>D-(rj%*3x|yyDwcFFwnL&xryOFJs1Z1Ly}K6!(QM{k3d*j~G4K$JzMiLZT;5#?*D^yR$| zIM1!qU;Tqj9k%Myt3Vq4>w+@GnLCxase@llp@iDGd4TIujH84oQ`>Ya+H=ie(xxaJ zvkNtzo0a!W-b!%p^I_DJV-9PHPA-puIYLa_B3WXl{e?AcTqBPZ$2I?9=heL*ymh&g zW23tp)z#XumxQXV^rgVw3i9P1ihbZQEH0(cy1q_Vf%SJB}I1H>ECvf+qmq_6FY$>oaYXj6GI%q_x7ZR6Y=YXxlPV*S!<7 z$Q&zG*Mt`?pd$>ZgWKpZ@+DdC@2sgG4#M}mXusPcnU;-Ks!xViPYNwcZFhNH8IXTY4+Aj{eY;% z*8f|#)R^RSl+^fS(Bi*>Tq|gaonK>)t>w2OhjlX^Up*S#woV$PK=qahj0>2MRNO(W zl5!rA?g6JWaRaR6c48i`9+9y38IG%YCw0!pb#*nKD@L7fYm;oZ1ApBKE}M(Lml(Y` zLtq9QnJinpGM>vgbtwVM$hDhNZoyy9{dhvrdq}^kf|V7dbAIs-VtB321Z7l}qxBfT*SWo0@oyN!F(aCR+_}`RVI~sFqqy}tWL7=1XL+3ggUZ-chv2^PWSh^r zf^<$X{W+==qT_6*YJFOppFt>6NT1fmXVB?taM;L~u!d}MicTPA zj?IZwQsm5VI4isyScFf>)BkNL*|eq&r^&%e-gQ}PcfjR#)XdZAqABM2azTo&poO~d z0A$O7$sE1=p;A)I>SXbIRmZh`JYJ2UXkF!`=!9H{{o2)R?b#hRz#G*4AKtL*iNmzx zBZWwjdnV%zWBT`n$Ldio+_Ni!xc zrhhhF7-{XSE|HamsT3PI!>6vuv(X~3Vz-?Rc0`>-C*kUOKe&4i?1=|x%&W26yJIIsPj9HCJ=ewBS^M>bParvpR1kYwOpr5}EQO&XMy&A?wTtuebX^ucNbVif$& z%0dj_?BrS?QS49JBtx>5nxVeIua!=~R*U0ccFY@le9Zg0VyF9B`^VL0&q!1J-}Oc3 z-~^12K9g0tyFBx8mB;J)oMhMLLeZ}I*NIj}8~1=LGk*+xM-PYp(OGzPGcMdtp9?1P zzqD7k$E8n*5P8SzcTD@-d(a;r04K*~U#?iz^!!-k5Hl$D(RX-F&|jHETCK4BnoZX6 zO^90}aq>eTuOv3@S3RcJ9f5IETNOk_SX}&l)@6L08*0V@y`gbbEC#5`;1390OE zD?y?M%;>&IA2UWJSi}5DN}cbwN>F5UBOBUcP>uvncW*fN@|I?Q7gDJXg&XUNqUfdB zJC!KHONLizZ0&DxI8#mNs9p9ZsEx|h6}n}ADAaoj?kHy7t~;Z@2(_nXPT)BGsA_b1 z{gspES1a-WZ$!_smPqbtyE?v#64o-~ZutLzfPZPmgQps3fgcTa_v=&WQN4>7q!*f5gd&##Blwnc+hz{38xem)&MM`%cy}L=MRI=4!U9 zTNajUA>tjn(kdY!u5))(rjrC?@os|)egO}+ASw}W{3SraLdkoCEWclXq|I%wd9;%t zfIHT>(o5V9*F|utMKy9GYN;oj3hb8gvz0=1)2&@$Ggu{^`7LGgyc~Xv`QzQ1;R8#U zB-WpU?M1WnE|otqI96wO^}N)q^0G|qxA?qViAf!1_K`fh%%1Oje&WN6o5|r&V=jOM zJjIw9W+R|f=&UKQy|~|x@12$?x4mX^O&D5Xv%Z`s>C2$Af(q-HerL_d(_|SJE-HXT6%p z5(KLUP!_ymjC&W#ZhUlyT{Vdd3Tux2QT3c%%-|mRjv#Lu+jW5G zD9_7Q09Oen)yaAH`mCnYFOSb7v}$>MjDP-Rvr9{aY$gjlt;UkOw}$+N=Txq&CG6yL zJ~$M!U}6=1*Qbn_YqM8+l^M~JKB%lIeF-ik3@sEw8(@jkz|(KD-weX<=ONHci4C%V zC6lDFzvmPJv;0jEg48M!kXpW!Ndo-_`@H5J#LNn>FI&K{jj)Sw`WEWNXkS2HOGP1S ze{9g(Y!@+!cEKiU@8)$cWHEwSfPZIL9g)Xf!R4l;2rd(&&3(tsYVh?b)rxR1L9ywk zl`Mb8*!A`<-p^h9&EhqUKIY7)|7I<`teFHZYsv)>g6rtf!^(2mC6&0fzyg1X*3D7CU@~>8Xg0c+>r z$ZD(gb23bu#-E{^t^H+e5>=UEN5egJ!6TWqmP&kvS8?(Ty*?eY z$=AVPqkVZG=uPl{w_{V78J!Kx)pxmt{2>g6)%^p(m=Y*2l{NmCOx$B@&|X^G(Zz}ODVzP8@@7kKl;CjzjI!8jFr9-MHx z2N`&rYR9#daAu}i0c{5EsW4n4%0b3^N=ZFOA|LmJLG)cj=A`*2QoHH3LNeuON4e>W z)_u?Y)rx+*&MW9p;7}+!D%wD7ns%>RNAxy`gFG@UpAamcq>A1n4X1rk@TDL6NobDt zQ#zXBK~a(x8x2P|7amNRB9qJ3bW=!2sI$bnm_kLJXbTYi_1l1LF3zWY9@+5t-et^e z9@Q2MvlzJv46}U>Jwb`VUSagiKtL%FJDmqBQ|6G$&xnxS`d#5n{UUv!f&%XCGrRz$ zk2^y2R{ZrC=c7FV3dTX$Zh8tv`A`6+q@)`9i-{5Y{YgOdTt3W&Wjv6TIQI~kq5I8H z;A~heVSQ>&Eu3TAP1G;40Hm;qHfZXn+!4FCu0y=$ojirlqUxoQQrLs$Ir01Sn|R>} z!yAmz2q)}Za%wxC*Y5-Swcc+P)?J*j5niD;qfKaL)9?g>Srx368NYe`TF2JW5SB># z>KG-O(eHK;mk|hKIa83HsAi9uEltKeRb(XoRv1=BtEnj`fE|gE)uFwSMAL%%T8xzN5Ur1Wozk#)RKZt-M)6{AIAu^cXQVpLA|| z-`-@?>|0CXb=)#Do(583XO|vHM?V*&LdMfu0wPS2N>&b7*+*QrpehOB(Q^IYg8JxQ z^E{oBvc=tb*N#C}_sNb=34^dM`n1_%t@4X_a0|>YY(d_PlKt}N2c5U80hlmN?#ia& z(-a=Un_u5z%cm_f!%)F!oLGdNi<(JPjf!cw`S%EgdoP9Ff^kv=7dbPPFnW^ihC@4T z!Ojkgw4?-VeBvU>(cce*7{9h}pouRTLU)qkIS)&jw7K>ZhCCs%MTNMy4Fqk{#ke== z)9ZA~ioA9V22uPB#)Cfi<*mmqx{Gt)IyUJ8#Utrfe?w>ARu;xk2P~YStSo(>esw?T z)D33LF7h!ZHU4(<7CC@?);zzD?VQKQUHWaPd#Mi-0DXGuR8IsweUuw+<7T%yq0(^R zttU|rZ!*MvFy+x!-Kl_qvN8UAd23xOh@k|)QxQq$QSPAGW)Lv=U3U}f8cnPI*uY)# zjYuu`L6zW~J}17vz}&&4?+rc={$~R=7dL=uRT`}7M+b08lmJ02{fgn4anIqGt56U! zJAD9Vvu7iGT98)axVYS|>RT1ucbqY8)HPSySKWZ|%egg}Le|YJM|@Gl?do&z!tDCV zTtbny$?VM!KONcgi?{LT-`s2yMJbr@EEj81OXy{RH0a2E|<@#6ENCW5K zxz$QP*&_>=2bnxd3<|^Y=fqTEXxccrRm&_3DGz_T*A70hk}ZV3=*~jLKsQ{qO-)(U zR-KmJv41mLY*uO4B~i#lmtD1;+8%wdiH#<@Qq`_sg?Kw0OkqmDSS^cFom&!OBz7T( zX%~BtBRXnoM)SnpKypqz436_#LIw{){H6~T|7>Jt%#e+KFgzf-T@UQy4J>#2;Gfgimb#p|>_&LPUW-20F4m{u008c@buF4fPiD4Bb-dkx!b8Gf+({3gh z*o|be%Q3lDp$h3+Aa0o<%um9glL0on+xt;bfg1ZmBToC7E9#uqE{Ig|RTEds%=&Dn z=?dRakm6bkRCj?sj|C2zz13Lg>~|F=6|U)jFi>Q6Ddxb~5K~J#4%dG`eE)-}8KO=D z7n6}+gMe{{=?BI>&dxw_*Np)LwLZ*^$%9FvQ}zzy2XPFCu)td0LVy;Zr}lBSLuIi7 z6=N+cpN6|v;tLXr+DnA%_qo~zy*MLPlbniT>59!O{!kCSvSv#2-tE4q0~FKzZg}6X ztG1OWRjmy5@q{?zYrHdWHA_CKRh}oqD#E6%w=Wn^_~l~k!Y|&6reM zqP^~{5$TKoHm9qxo>=GFhws4Tk-ejEeUqN?=7?8Rf3x|#^sd^WSSaC$RqdNDJ&hz| zXVz^ALgV65dzZ8)E{#o7;r3^HV|ht%lG&q?fgeNLNsK*Fb{`hygOO0d&E1}g@c`m5 z1-O%?&qUd5?c`-ZLg;+_R41%!Vy^=@Y`n~On@dwKZ>@EHtew)`#r=9#(vqxY;1ZC7 z_|dE_%HjFrk?3)GNb+q<8(X%8tFxdz4mCh+t3vQffnLs#oc9|^TB2u|O}!;(Pq_w1 zKfCA;3pG8R`pJ7ae<)##iW78EK~wH4Ygc9X5cP7=s;b_{*l-Fsax^i7#$ydAm zRRuiZZ7ut|Qr%mj7+>LcW4hT@ehrj_mLRSo(Q~55n3Y8#fEku^K2aGRtzaZrpQITt zO%<4$T`0QCUe?YiMYdEJ&89wuZV_~g(1B%AEd|Cd2JTaP`$`ZvpWul!RWyJ0 zdMlPiiR-;;bqQoIwKlMt0JlL6m0WMu|!dNj^8jveHt;D77^gaQrKm_n^G2!AY9_*sGu(UNVvtL z1U|%Cc$?f8R1trasX=xX#5o3ZAdRzK0j=@ft|p5&|~p!u(5R`#yzy7L5_8qe-POBLiuIa z*~*?Z%<=Wqp$Q^INuet&3nI8Sq|?DHu%^Sg6Jk>tQ7t=~7wTv_L&HQcJM%!3;gZP+ zOoj|~T#T9J*B^U{A^7%F(_FC+3X%y5fcKL$;Kzg?PYf1!*PV^Y`om6`l~-O;W9(MB z14t|(lqOiPrR#_^o19ycVbtw7>cXBK2y8q$e` zM506`*Os5&T+@EY6{uD96}TuM$mk% z&&jfrQZN1mRObxiFZOEJp+sWoA+|j=sY7DP9A)NXz=yBXIe zti5k12aVUat>T;^Yu&xhUOId2u$}ur!!DS{OvQ4k@GE7y0V#|G=U?U$50_O*CsHK^ zVB4{3qU9K|-)#cY&KJ)Zmba&mwi_&x_a4n!J}0+p7EOAT{WZUCYruU+voU1-8>6R@ z>v}CIJ&y2|*_WZg4{HGs*xJL*-B#18{lqD$N~jZkhmZJ|_8vN?dJ6$}HJJWgi*1x< zJ-m$BPW={1t=#48DfC=j-CM$$llKwvj9>A3aMhK=t#y-_BuqB+#-0&v+(4jtnG^HI zh!c~Ox#hcPi`m1Oh+K)%+qtA?1s&_Ib@f+U;VZj=Q^2sJvYlT7{K!zhu)9Bh2TpBk z5@AZU!^JFA$3 zPm`>PHB)YvoO9+;ekyM(3Eue^V!W2SzDNt{=THOR0r@b?gNQm*+7(8`%I>>=WnF6* zIxH*2NuO|ZJj5XXaWYm0>6AnqU)YNZ+dA5VL>xpx;vffGNn2qjQDJ*KTVY8tJ8?Og z|KAU|#L&zCZMpJKi;Jk}(Z>G17?s>}+iB|^m8{O4ucb<-YE>=*MXDAVR*uus$tqV) zUtoQbi;B1y|8j%6=-#8go)8|qe~igu6TyEzg-#%Z!(@ud%-6?L{q9}LJd=F|k!d8F zTOajt4{=nS`dmg|4;FAC7B>zt51UnkW_ON7+InouJV=`_Ue>5pr2FO#z}OE#sYLyVm^iuz~b4q6eea zz}n+WV~e+n@oQx`7mdNiAdaG^5R25QhPgI|P?w;cg-Q@`Pu@JN{mfN+^rUhQu@dI2 zJ+fM4tb6+N>*t*fEmspJxvx&!2YN>e`6bOxJ3AJx20u?|?g3X&+5as2|KrvDTl+oj dT>f3iY<>I!eH>FqF!3cMCGgqV!4Osa{{kYfHZcGI diff --git a/research-protocol.pdf b/research-protocol.pdf index b766f158c3e6e0440527cf23f694f3d2e437be93..d85920df80e33efbb4cfa319b157d56bb343d891 100644 GIT binary patch delta 8209 zcmaiZRZtrY6K(Mz#kIwuxVyW1C_#e??qDHmUm3CnlUG+EmrOa{OIG$=;0DD_|0UJcnI*;dozVz+ZF;d8{O&JWk>d71eFnqvH+5C1XnQpHY4 z*48xQE(vUg_dz;A2Ds^2Tia(qZ^k2!?3bGew5+y!HXRC=t6OoYV!e`{%!#ebN?4|=fB^6gj@I5 ze)E_%hR+M&+95x(IJ6kwa_c24Ed0-F$O?Z zgvOb0G5I2Svc}$r;9GpQWXvqpr?2=~XlGK*4ptg_iaqTR5?@#a@@cY5lnBwPpz zbO__YA6$DT_B$e1Olj~&Auu+La$Hezl9u`LQ>%nm;mclg&T5(zN7A3ulb2TTi>3Zn zgcCaH%bgaCr>3lSKz=RW45eLW1rdyG`%ZEhQ+tJtEPO$>l^c$XUEjPp81VAsC*oaM z2j)oBNi^7o?apQoj>#y(i!)J}PQcKu?Mj+ooR08XMoe;SW}{iWmjP0fS<`=?6TSqX zbk+)*{H!Nr*xp+vF|I+04Hf7=6p_^SLH92f@U?LOB!4nyRlk{4L#f#@&sI-1WqU4v z0#DSJO2k-YPcWj+sNo;8Fn`;^P6jhn(ldS|`oBKyiN7?DJ=a8WE&dLO}yuOLNOiBMAcl8m> zP~QK?$*DkxB_864wM+IV1g{$XQnD@}r0=tmg{kr^Uz6}WkWYS-oY`-$E2r{wss{%% zur2vSbbj6k?5Lkv)XBJ+vr@Vksa{u|X-YOx>|hYFB}jQ-3z>l!7?1&s07y0BE;qv3hd%}cF zTd10CJuo@$(fay+rh{2Hc4c2MkYbLy-E{9@Cu#XN@ls1&N7J#1NaRkkhSH_q?+My! zvE!ar&hn|Wak@C$l$YejuRPcMngYCyZ>Ju8@lq zuaxhX*oSt-MtD}q4ZT-%-A4y?J5f)60x{04?Wujm15CEPsqg1PRAT)8J*v$2lwzEc z>wEaza$ZF^B@+c`@bn4yzl*V3A%SMp3KzkA+<5dLn7_ZC$-zGGSkV(2T?mt){;gs< zA%21V1&?MeoF=dW*6XR0^8nwau3UyzP5JaE@lp-QXb&im4fuYdux5(FV$mPh$QSBe z=D~id+RPL_jLSkxm1iH4`#2;EG_~L0w9U|XHk^HWhrZ17T^ilP>$ojQW8j<$ zkSS2(?&dFU@y02Qo+ucJ`+xp2i57-B_tN4k-u|>oFD)Aq`aBzN!|L`94ocB?bAN+l zO~#5Ie%{kujl>?CfI9R3g+@u5wOqciAZ%;U-Yh>%pUu*3Dt{aB)?4>mTxilVC$aM? zzkKpV-`MwSz_7Ak)v9z(mloLyf1{~+&HK}_DwlcdCbSSIVsqv&8L}$eYXK4H5j)&| z$OAcPOh{BjyxX4HGfcbl)(OqHRLpQ?M9lMGIz#-XgtDN3rKg3%d9d+MH%~%(DXwbv z1V|?6XE|+2U)L>c&))cDw8Efk#we>Ov*N5_MR8GKQ8_Q1spWA3-Kr4FrNw1ZQ?f}w$6VWFQlXB9>uC-U=mglzVsJHZO*i&M3{k&%Hn+53u~{b9JhxTK#&`$O03?1#_A9@oG& zQ3?O=J-s~f?%EN|Z~HN!#PSaGM9~tQ3TAbYLfJ*~+SOZyQ|S^cUvqKfxcwpp{NC{? zV0~>1QINe*KvI+UUyvdArmpfgLKlF?dhmeeAL*JJ)AqM7-~nsh6nokzR4%e@Rj!12 z*(>svBYdwPVB`A-sAO0Bx1gT9BW@z@?-mo^PH`(Hg910jPWk2C|;*pP~*Eu@ct8V3s<4;`&{{5>(@@65)rtOf0yhQRjAK}qiIc`be6-6E3n z%tM&VYD!VP`KaVo@6YWus3phE@_*u*KuhKSG-xe}?3<>~Rnex0bI?59!Wp)v&@gQU z`Qw;MGvyf~BDO|Z=5ixsRh(V*V=V!a33ACC7+e`0`L6X}?UVm-!}nS&oCO7Cp{As>y!~!-skyoC3c5wkY%Gb+Y@x}o0o-|IGzf0N z?B`^0?;oT_+tbc8K!Rx#1wYp|hu_7g8$dLZIJaRr%k@dA?4-LrJ@#YJ`V$h>kgxXt zynG)g1Rb{T<-w0U4Z@=OsCGtZWKTz4rz=0pIgBE5!6^8*4){}kwX^OeH|ibXoxseP zw8?L_`9ddj0%*&`(P#YKfw_dLm2nC}<~9K#HGZJ5tp(O=QRM@R*>TxRrM+t3X%2VP z=Eb?!Exa*JGv%|Wo^=V`R);M97y} z7HaYvWn35Gj-SWQgqDf?8IfTai(X60lyHl>;Y<5nX5n4mbdD@#7G|qDgfUlLk%C3o~pA{I&_F zmgG>cwHftCsNx3(2NQe+pniIjTJiMI(H!swM+Qehso?mUS2Aq>q-+V)+*ZD0`57Ci z5(YJ;lh4g#OJ(!?8!;217*-c?N&PkgFK;R@8u_>^sb^7cNlq*JcsDX%OT4BqqE(}&hdbj zc!;YKJQgXZ{t~IiX)4Qt&O=2j2Jj%9q7QP=!c>;Q-`kS-C6j|4OghbtOeo_oQ#VaQ zog^vaEAw`mES!-xu`CrI4aW*J#e+#J$E9b?%md{@rvHPArjlWh6uhNDfJ3WlVi7$% zL4u^iIi~rElqvC(PmLc=aKXQ~2!!IVZ^&wl{%T0XdYpx*l;m=9*}~*>ByU7BRC;El zSh9byA}1Cs(Noe1{sG_(y8@Fat1yXzKSd>>_F#Aa@thf7WzeG9H&lw+17_iTr9%(>poHA2U}{m;lTQVCb(j`*-2XkM$uUdK^zif})TF zS(zIa?K1J0vkZYO$|1W4B7zSer&uqbp#xKqPT}Z+c{%_GR9dEL)P)cKQv1H-(`K@x zL4waDj1>SY31{IHx_cHU*}xHiHn7mbU%Bqj&^OCWoDnG`RDh@KFY7&^V&QQ9R~1j{ zbNh#ck>R&wDXM!s7Dca?fffCsO^tUhe8L8v?!@Q8tU$S6;}qPo3>=*gW&Y35{k$sb zG22Vf^})q)Ojl>-*s1~EZme6!9=4;Dm5yX(HYo87#UCAxf)fDh@Vk$L-cIP3$8MXK z9jx_EKQ{NmA+2o8^*)ye)AjS({@gpGa9=60R%n;MQKJ6y-bjYkC=5K6it~ZM1Q>&l zaeMl@FRYAep62PmLV@Y3O#vOYVOF=43)>qGY}!Byz)kI{$hJrsVn*;>sJiQkF|7Hb zqj8g7PM7<`tIZ^WbUUh`rl84*sN(DVK;I0!$(OLtqfZRlkD2#}e%E)avp$#iSow## z&P-9Dq6Ua_O(FVhzyM#67d0M0)SxA`ub|+(_I-Zrp~seYP^BRXZU=2hT6pFl01YBB&lM#6)u{ z(mnsUHZ3knp(3PqK852Y4W*5JBTuNCz4$RYc)S#(J#E@{Qi3EM^kkTgcewA~n2~c! zdR<4&rDV4q=w|HH3soDPq1W_~gMGuaXL(!iN}-;=S(&2hLc(rhd_<&FPRPns_hcy6 z>zL(s>^w@Ezg~C3dC01#wNrlqyF4ciiL!MZLZFWZLr~tE42uN=l8V$N!B=~kzLgKwq9{Y?Zzx<0p)ad1JaQyie)mccxoZ1$e7kZ&m#UY32G zo^l!cdBp^*MF6WsLZZO;_R`PSztiDP?@jfd`kB8DTSP*V#~-{@waQbd%UwL?K+=G1$N#aw)uQ$m!j5Go)e=gi)3~CF&MTT#5jk70o{EtIFPJd7x;ug$ z^imF|mwGCO(q3FzHtVFQr3Rkano_t5khZ+dakmVM?z%Q+?7y*9M8y|bRx`MOp0r>^ zvvH`BPVdCMQiT*s#G=vg=~c^fIT6?)dTKM<+m#|S$U^W$^M!c9rU@BlM!hzG>%j|9!mu>u-nfx%v3ZTVSu^@Snjy~T2m zf6uFP&D@rinf+!uc(L1m4tfJ^I?yB=Je{drdFdFu1fIg}TMV;~mLsY4*6=0|vu={E zjwHANmZ!;LvV9vf*~vGO!vXo239%2Rr^iUPy>k!Xy$ zO!<#y6pcMazN4&ojs~=NbnCkOm(a?+T5rPY<@&}faSZE@FuxVYts0m|DMRNiy)w%8okxY zGi!WeNEb>I!XeICdUqf%f^3xAx$oE%Dhv|Od`p8gijtndatQJVw>CDoKaQI4 z-W!e-`jyl9%U?>Taf~0;=&6cslz4aNzbX?C=LVt5&Bb1TA1y)`DB}~R&3+v!6se6_ zM?Qc`1l9CNs`7^Jd(#7FdZYPq9rv1mg4#OI7615DL}y#3Ajizgn2%ZL!C%doMduVl zsUvglF@zNL{3x8SLmFfdV9s-rf*kYq%H`-gNoS+9*92L)CdJN&4a&>SbEWUI94H5`)TS#D4J7Tj{l{Mi zDxO;8;FVKNBoDnpk*sPOW1Sr=Ww4Bt8m&t|k>M6JT=CeEcxpk2Vm%)81wL zY8X-rcDj37acxD?ll)SBHfpSLeXLt5fVO4+ zXkAOyYUNr+NgwT&|8vDv16FDZZtQ9KFkxn}Tx58%`=e$E&2$>F(<;R7E~zgdh^VRp ze>9ahs3J0+Iwr_G2ooB|RGcQx@&9OX<I6~gLc@rra{F3BU*;XX7)Vb-S zIkQzzgdh!h2Ir78eIB|TyVm{I43!UR=$FSGrB^opM)uf4g@rP&nph)_)=Y!$Mr9*< z6id0Hm@W4$zhtP^a4UoLi4OIp4e&%AN;?Or^NEr8H8d2nJT}=sL&pI4&ecu%hHzOh z1hpMQVKt*ebeH48-_+M9j#^jXgNOAj(~mh0lg;;flZWS!JJ%Nnf0d1-YUq7S(DcT1 z9(C1D?6sNj2&TefXw9O@kzZh5$8Z|t(nJ7LGfViTfx_BOq#^Upc30)=S7T;bqXef9 zDnSgzq6sy#;Hn9se@8WGiXG#~arQP6yzG}ul0FpX2?zZh=7Tg$WSc&_U8JwSi^KVP z0I!oNDH1M6CW%qy538G9zo5fdr5~gd39Fcoaw6_7RfVSU$gYoM7q@=M?F~Z&RT6xq zXy)OWHqX7=_F~_=x%c(eAKGG{=U~n4bXm>kJ{P-Hj9IYo_YxA*WgkoPaAH8D}1 zcZZske4HRG)*Q%kTF?|A>f5y^;v~ zWimTs#WdxYLcI3#_`g(w<*>e(S-iapgK1(Tk?}yREzt^sKArE^gM@j?67xcGV5Iv? zTu**>?nE495c>^U>`&2xoRrWaX_}eG3=~)@HWCva!_T%91-;I@_u*5!{}5NOVQeHe z`PqM416T;kJJGU8OIeY_x+LS&IJ?XROkl~}N)q38h&EbPt%my%6V|Mg8LIx@@YZRD3byBZBW>EcsuAK`};0(cm7JGw5^^|$)Bi2%MI2P8VrecY9`cwmW2 z=3=|n*)Y6fY3+e>{+cmHBfQpt+r9Mc4Oqcy;c3$NFaOAAYd(J-@vOOsl5CBrViwE0 z=l0+$ZA5%mPZNJ8_hEJ4Lk_L?OY7QLQs%rRcHQ+b#Q0KusR$6N=>VYxQf1r?sLn&r zv|OC7R%Z_m7d}l)8kEg7I#!+Izu956oS+y#yniocN;U5~00cz&UF;pg)`H|2xp#Ma zzw1f5Zn%qqmyrxEGVz?M5ZvoA^;vq;oth-!=Gy1jhgT7KdM`X6Fthp*LAvK+^*C|; zD6tPpk>_w1tH~3nX)m*Wn?_pV@ewL4?J^bJ4vAf}Q-7jw>eFhM)@t|u)t~I#uQ$-+#KhH#>Av=@ zn3dg_SHdcV>DHPf*M3^-qw`k}#(2#oofge1&+paaB+a8~t|(QW(OtX-SD>nvOpopU zX6fg<=S#sKt}yU|x=Y$q-qoCsU9)UsYv@SXy4vq&ufowl&Z?oTW&PpIt)~B4kC1p- zn4Syoj^Ig4eR=2Be?LlECZT={_3zpoC zj>f@zj7A+H3XE&K!!ozx_TDrJj6bcxll~W=N1WD`Rz*nL(}&^mkC_tMME7gq`VN*$g z5(2`v+G~N+%}O5gkr$_U9p`5PKgj(R@p&B)Lm+}}w@De-*GgWfd*l$XyDtAT5!;o3 ztB*Wxzz|%an{LO<(d`Hw`}5pFjAy}R_Q%FBhWQ+aYcRHjjGq@*vV~;yjCR19ZRej6 zIAq%wcXCrrBA&Gc4R4bT9B<@{itYB6x_8qTnWzR3TZ=kxMSapOupD*hDp|BiH#Ydz zFj(15+_?|39I?bh;PX#wIlkDH$a#SAcR1WI1a^+4zX7V~aqxvw(X4A$bc_9tFmvn^ zN5nb#lAUg%q#d~5Cd~VT57EIL->a@ys^Y_{G+$pYxzcvl=8oBpYv&}jnhm8v`)aj8 zo1QsdQ6uyChe5?1b6IR_Q56_^L3bw7AMcGI&(r%ZbCaN;5C6SN+GZajF3m)nP2hfQ dTQob%u2Wbx&Jb8WArd8k59`ARMQtUl{{u0I1jhgX delta 8180 zcmai(MN}LNu%&6--QC^Y3GNnX+%k)3AxLm{cXx;2?(Xx?o7G#*rdGE$ zx4wJooT~mJ*r6iW>bzhOzqmN^4|g|fb0=i)RpW#W`;ae~VV40>9V$#cIVBmvh>>!f zyiSoLFoa}URQlF@1U|1P*;E9^dfRJhLLx(CA|rD~4F%O8cU?T*sA6D4ah~5%RDW1y zMXizgyb~XHnu`aA-FA#k(xbj4Bn93 zq^tu_cWxSjcl_0OBr4NxfO@nT&#>?Wbd3iwPCsdy|Iyl(HA^<+Whot*hq+hrg&Z+$ z8@XOO3u6=$rosr+4;>dlm&cg`vw7yTXews9?TyRyztuaTy{w$S2r!qv$S z(W&GE#pm;bp)7_QzPJVHQ#+aQ<@D{0!$RO)`dR1cA#)x4C)83xpLk*}7&lQMlpmz( z(8q}ye))_i?irnc(R2(?HBFDpy;#A^CeqfJ07twgIFk1nSflNm+7m86>!2Ulm(R?y z@tajtn8txnf6i{-j59H@yK>r7_!myGu#h;S`U(n3=z!!h#|#XL7scz%)9s6oV4BI1 zpni64mUAx~$6-JwHyj!;=MrD<<{zl+?`0oiKoLn_Evp%8ru7DAtB9dva!W5bHb4Zf za*oZ=D2kZo-s&99cbWzqEIM>*;hW8i49`LksmDG!vp`_bRZBKr!H!ihiQi^|4%#JTZhE&_v8#+(&pcl6urjh{0w#zBi2=1>~74ncx%{ zhwhT~zbzhKZV7h#hNk}wS%|SrS+#utHL;Y!A>Fhuh=l(3)vVIlcqw*7uyYrR+{St% z^bu(*du?0$?HvZgzz9I|KX@7b5&(fi{=@0=BTC3qKPvsAl>o~?SwHV0W!2;XKXC?a zp0?lnYO6}IFoI0sUq-tCk%^JckPa^LOn;b40cWDLEzpd#drsmSe7P z)L8lnhcIQoM}QFMqdohyoVaAXQTOZ*0^i!}d6G?c4a&~iU##KLg_<;ZFi4tC1kQ&X z&<|FPUL3Dp`LVDAJ`Es=ksBuGf2_UEvYCDP38RFfsEr$FMBHc@wOhg@Eo~jEnav9P z5@=BNOXCJ~>C&^{c?Kc=6UYD-R`j&nW?Vy9g%gIQ&PI9<8(!9=GL5$}|hf~ymlAdsysiO?_0)5BFwt%H*`|FdJ6Ek@a`_|PJWspZQ zP~OkEl`;yrp3(Ok!Tt$44nT`34){EGOK$F*9`_uG`zZc?-2wiT? z=zS0;CxJ4~;U8VbG9EzFwJ{By#pI0@`10?*ZVk-E3>c2OpHDgLiXz!%Q?nD>Gd9Q= zeY~S$PGWY9YM@*~1Dv!kdv;Ve34HapyllR{)Er^RH@URo+=v}}ShIU}!Vl`Jm->jB zV64%rpn~X8i~Tm_!)@_MM5h3k)xbqd>{=i@_ec0@X@lnp7>Y9rtl9U z&0Kl8heCNd((RsHvnw+V&dhd6s-8A|<*nm)_oDraNr)f$=w;g9%1Kq49fl>0El~zl z+pY+|qX?m~u1|p6%frHd(=`NDN_XcuD`y(HB^EWX{Gy{8L--7!TiKh2L$cxHiKZ_* zv1AJiI~rnK%nvj9kLs^==7?nIQVFzh?5P_X%_|Cgk!9ikQJt?PaCj3K`0mJVUw9J$ z>M;-0sOvIT9{~tHuspYZ3w7_iuQ8?vTeA7V`KUorGvFlhp`0mI3fuc%x4HDqAPRL~ z=rowmO&Umim$9Rwm&H0u;3Lx_Wl$v|W=5d(IV%o&+bgDIeC~R51bT?Q77f;IeI1I~ zWn~f-PGT9=xvR9Mgis@2eYs*7cy6&G1h@&gKjkmS7o-_m`G<_8%& zgmB`9U%unDoDmk;Th>ZqWg1KBHE}gV%7JifK-pOk_$-^P3NuBB*eDp|LZY;e^GHwBH5?>2mN@T>XL>Usi*Dt76bE@2QFR&lsB|w zgVtaTR5Rf(?wAL(xw3DInbq1d zxiGsWgi`DwsjdNkp@Bf+bgMk`}KFbA#}l55~5 zJuFki$g5^1ncL0SS1O0xPfEvtXermI+$=cS?ek0>jEnheGAbI-mVZ-7OzSX7hWjf$ zL9)3d(TZQvt(&p{5l(&?`bP}BO$rolMIjT^pj#B7y%<|mrJ4ppj1@O3K3O{rA7{^7 zTuhJ2HEe+B0ejE-QJxG)DH{DLR@*&;YMYArJADu!1EwgrdpPZjOf+vvz6sS4g0QXz z+aZn2Y{mid02jd4wiT$L9Cl26csPO~o2VHc+(g?P&NJm~6??EQ_?6-H3N|Tb#E^P` zeX1LY>3K}BRj|P=iH35pvoH(}Mo$>|I@WZOtQ zh0{IjVg*T9+4)L6cQIB!<7xW%iIM`K5iyT~zYI+mL@6c89xrt{PF;C^RYo&4`j5b=j%Z-l;1waddVhZ81pbh@0xC9z zC&WWNCdGq{JZo|3>wjgl9-v_?|Hyr_zK6|_5$_3)S5GLIC3+s@Vf3ysiZ)%C$o0K` zQoL{dXeiCjik&=>f4<_R$bKi8OL>;he)wcH;V2t=%86Nt;b*=}940 zS^5e|@r~iqK880L5^PYR&-+w;dIX@n7<8=lV@A`&dIw&4DW6l85N5Vp3{5^wo z{m_?F{dSRLqOn1u1SM=;(aJb|(3);toc~%6!pVB-(fTfy5$cYg>-A><1wM5R0f^NB z<1>g9l<_QSG+dwWdP4GSwRqMR_fy2l@5jX-Srsl@=9dDc!5*7n`yx?n##*kh{ zV{VeeR-5<`y~qV<$s)KIgZC5?MG|x4QR8U(x#yKK|E0_+bZ7sVq704-2d~a=pFu%r z_!cCqSy<0u3+n~aCaD$2YeY?_{g(}#6uc@M?HMt;VpdYi7M3#5Wtb`@->pY_2aDJD z7V(cpN{F(uV-Hdne8gOm{{YBAL}U*zwICIOh5Bl1vw)y;Bx{N&`$)38Mf|3e53_!Y z+Elhl@vLGN5e-}gXAK@fZz;>UMSM)?OL6bNfftQ^9^sn%Cl-;6eSwRn9}b^O zT8tKvW}{qz9P2`P8H?LD--HB7jPW9W+1# zZVt4#um|ac1}K5%&L?QYu&4e+z#|Hab8{ohZ-z8l-(BD0^-$PPT+a@ijC^(qdlXqz zHmM^c;QOgJ=KtFdVG#rX*RrfI=j!Zu(mUE@d^nwoJvQ?hE(1%&S>qhjlyqqksU;{p zQTR$_Mi5*UlL7LUKi9692>5?J8CJ=Db#&2@f%@53;Z6s-j42N)=}oZ0a+-YF!qOY9 z)4QUQz8Bt`#di&7BW-JGbFlj5gY^{0V~^9fu>b2gna?O(R@T*^1yUEk<8R>{`=+6i+y?d8S}tPc6_s$V?aO)l#r3T+R4BoX}}^GMYA zkcTAqOT|qRbyuTB7xk@i_NmjN=tai`4?nrILYLPiW$h%e&^Uow{;I<|vb3EaUT@>> zjwKovqfFD%;HBKy?MxSCGt7SXuWw$-&V%O3zbgNL(6|dE!oPjZQHSiwAk3@{V6zBU zG6z7-c*;b#83^naN^H;F_x;8k9XizI@>rgR*>{;6vByj_>s*gRkAyp32&btN&G@b3 zj@dYVKJa)u;3ia=aqJIEGYX@1j=GD2By#IxT0lG?=+}F=*{13j{48^i*t~Ki&1RWI z_U&*EwBnfD9*8$zEMjW6JmV*B5SZShy%Xv}b;j=mJL+#*hcWISRpum|Q=57WW$@c3 z5$g{P#)_S7T$106D;HT;m5)4p$pX?+TGm13w@%ydu|G3>f5!&nTD?A5tR5!3E| z*YDxRPLN$M1^pmg@#Mg!>sjLfCPV{h0gP!;~J9djYh%CkMPNR$0@@gN^k6CnL) zOxGFPvdA%(pJIWkYp>>X#k1FSqnkj3zuL^Ws7V4~kS3m2oP7LXm5$SCRvQoSJ>(1A z$e4ohlc_u;ew68*HE^^J#p%qfeMTBQlJ036ef0f+DL&0yt2k3b=rol6xu)E1^H|vf zB40f>?t813uz50GSP8Q~uT70LXd3$NPF_iK{!i4*n8p(TT^HX5fm$KuBYdlF^{>NY zK|cysAJ3lnhd7t+=*4T=A)H&erg&a$j-`=AXPAmUYTk-Y11cxwjNlA8r)R3X47G(`becIqDSB7RKDTji9S+e zEO2;VAtKz29jU(cZGcqAMZ2xTCU*av`GmzOEhvkh{w9#-AxaF@ZSBZ6BP+fLBo3|r zVDR;NA>uo1tyI9=nj@S`*#kd`ICKgEE1BkE`CYS{gWdi^M#stbFKyBVuZKlw6rZMi zdKz{nCH={#G#W#ix~goNuJ>hp;z`5Xeh3I={2lGdKbw+XB1@IXVmPZ#%V1z}4A);u zgj&-vcumn5!8?NFSG$si6iXGcpx6twQ%qi0r#*!9tTyLc-*|3D2fvj|OoJMU{A8xs z{v!U?`FEMx%ACACvrh#}>*JSuVy2padjSW%!mhN-cG!jT4BUoy`WpY`E|b)n0MSa_ z3FZ#oEc;9MDYMn_ld8={mn~%Tt3xuk0C0i*l;!K%)>eR}tyiBlm4v|}=$5|2L>YH0 zKS|x?j9e#-dkXvzyAM|>)am*6njofx8$r86Z;@iwp_i_BD zz;-tMx383lM5bSWjP21t)E$~TkgM^47*=l;TSBi|QsI_|!%ax>1uk^Qst8X2w{c}UT22>H z1%FVPJXjeOZT!lu$8e9DQ}%Jpx1rf6<`fvuGU+dI1$PqvTaCkj>lVH%Ug;p3Ym3*Y zh+u~&TCx%yY=n0aIRzZ&>u-|X)A9G>(~C7}sQYR-ws+1=*XC3PYAa1ca5_#p?G-a? zAr*yHxr83GwnETjh!)v7^B8c7+Lx?E0vk=^IoV`8)KM>4${L28pN#S?@VV~`=fP}{ z*OZEXo6FR|b-FGUfE%QQILNX~J^%*AgPbwUmSK)CRu;<~qUtt80+(o2)$F63ump$i z_08A9MW>87@O(r-d-8^&d)2INcX&QE9P4?U-#hLQ+qAyFnqw|$ru20V&lvA9;R;1X zk%DDo(t0VR{#AjyFR2hMepCAW8HS09{yRMJX2eRy9UOOzJr1DkF~(7-_WQE;dnMz? zBz4tNnAgw|m8>Cm6Tee|-9#;4r}=$*wu(FkL054EE&6jhDE5?qjhyXNvrez_vDHyVbfx27w25Hl6Gw?U-jEb`}Lm*LXp0_js7MPc_o#3VWd$vM+V6o5}|X~=&XZU zpC*8JrJGsUnXvt>Mgi(r@NfRe{BXOl{L?ax(OeyMx!1(|RZ zjxe3ANV)SMc&*@Y@sbvH*}dGGk}t5~HOwq(*ur>PNCtYAoOcTg@e-e^k`fDCF~ZCx z3w}R-7Zs}a?AB#+BGqFFSNnrCiI(IcU3JrgN-c;9%%t$mSq&M^=cGRRNg%BFn?K9G zDx3>7`l~dP3N(!0wrFw9S7vP$X!&{~BMAGaj)hq}$>={ETzro>>;a98pI~8C>9stM z<9wd~z9Uk|0VZZ>cYP2w6aWE+jiotUVc@sx<2s-KuYC~29R)xMkcK3q0O&DTGFua6 zv^$?j!a4u_TYi9yq5zns*Z%DdA}^CZ36+JLOA4OW#t}x^m58px3$S2@lOZ}4jo#A2%rL30TB=@RDc+UQ-6J>!cbhS zJrC2_czy$<8Wq3@ScR;h0)U`xo73Hphlzqu`6=>S0TP+}@AYL`r@K`Y0q-|6pupR= zg>Rh+J9pa_{N_u#IXbEVAC4cM@%#^U$7T9~t&e84-dZ`@Ti5SDkKfKV>yR3E?QV}@ z4cOUjj`u&La!c~ghVJd#Gfm8@R49JA0YGmsdh}%!vyXq;NZv1go%De0RrDnVH;WVw z|8S?D;Ay;PnHpG9GOxWY4BdEQaTK{7DEm> zKB$Qp;d66!$`EV%21Uz3a9Gfy{pVl*zGHnmOy!;cMXOPbX)m6wUuk{-gc-3*Yk=eL z96{9A=RR%M4%QlZy;+AYcCB%Ct#!22S%%MI$7|h{e3!`-3Xm`8{muonk&ERug5Ncj z@+9jR+2P1lGlrjqkN+{HSlH#!c(+NIfr&w)2hS0|kY|`t$j5qB^jdJigwOBZJCzD?b z6h$TJwph4KCg*@mM17uin;dwr*;_0gTXwoaSv2q1Sw)Pvh6&Z5KZOzoi=7zP>2+Vm zm-eI9_LZ6ey1xBesVpzdy6Y1yH#^Tu7=a(YzvADy@?%!9OG>j{AYwcUG zT|maiJf;yWZVXMp8~PTf*ryCPSu#D{xBpsi7D5nWKjb%8u*@ z;dnMjLybLywc+6t65{2z;jyu@F}JYd6A<7LvKANp|0y8Gm;m|zeWhoc z*Vk1wC+xmH9Kno_NwU-_EWu>H)v!`<8&9{&Ry$zS`j%Ue6fH}vFc_Dh{*T(UH%xsR z&7oyv^YecFZ4o5)8nD&C@en901CJ0QBYH!cV@}sOsQZL3at+hjr~ZW1cFn^aHQL3k zi-cp29okew0P5PoBrU^EFlUJ{hw9oDAdTr^-o!N&g1#*4$6vFeU9>=q>75~rG8dGi zYZ>c_u zoqq5iYc%j0VQo{;KdR0Zo!(4zazG|C_EuX7`8>LZpMX}vy%@NG?T_|yNdo~xuSik zLDaRNa_%E*#?jrjUk`h|hN|od@rD&JCw3lWYsQ-6!l~mVQQtK%iXieP8oNd|8F26> z8@qzv1oay(hk8{*mtT?VSfcTpk@4@q_=l=%k1B6~+PN1R%GMf$hxn$C4d!+YUY9!S z(UV&Nr#8t4w5I}U0(xB<$5;AYUae!TvilKBtz*YQ9_31)oO^=goV-OR=B~FzF||j- vrt-JR+KV5p6E8(SOl3t}%E=E$UodVBzV9JhL$a{})M&%x>S0 diff --git a/search.json b/search.json index 60a302a..4a3c3a3 100644 --- a/search.json +++ b/search.json @@ -220,7 +220,7 @@ "href": "context.html", "title": "Context", "section": "", - "text": "I am Zack Batist — a postdoctoral researcher at McGill University, in the School of Global and Public Health’s Department of Epidemiology, Biostatistics and Occupuational Health. I’m working with David Buckeridge, who leads the Covid-19 Immunity Task Force (CITF) Databank, to investigate data sharing in epidemiological research — with an emphasis on the practical and situated experiences involved in data sharing.\nThe CITF is a “data harmonization” initiative, which entails coordinating a systematic effort to align the information contained in datasets collected by distributed teams of epidemiologists. These efforts to integrate the records collected during various discrete studies are motivated by a desire to establish larger integrated datasets bearing greater statistical power and that facilitate comparison across cohorts. However, epidemiologists must reckon with the diversity of minor variations in data collection procedures, as well as ethico-legal concerns relating to the sharing of individual health records pertaining to human research subjects across numerous institutional and regional jurisdictions.\nAs a scholar of scientific practice, with a primary interest in data-sharing and the formation of information commons, data harmonization represents a fascinating mechanism through which scientists derive technical, administrative, social and epistemic frameworks to enhance the value of their collective endeavours in response to disciplinary needs, warrants, desires and expectations. This study therefore articulates the motivations for doing data harmonization, identifies how value is ascertained, and describes the strategies employed to achieve the desired goals — including perceived and actual challenges, setbacks, opportunities, realizations, and lessons learned.\nThis relates to my previous work that (a) explores tensions that arise when attempting to establish information commons in archaeology, specifically relating to inability to cope with a superficial perception of data’s stability an intuitive understanding of their situated nature; and that (b) investigates how the open science movement attempts (and fails) to reshape practices relating to data sharing, integration and reuse. I continue in my approach that frames data-sharing — whether it occurs in relatively “closed” curcumstances between close colleagues, or as mediated by open data platforms among strangers — as comprising a series of collaborative commitments that govern who may contribute to and obtain value from the information commons, and in what ways.", + "text": "I am Zack Batist — a postdoctoral researcher at McGill University, in the School of Global and Public Health’s Department of Epidemiology, Biostatistics and Occupuational Health. I’m working with David Buckeridge, who leads the Covid-19 Immunity Task Force (CITF) Databank, to investigate data sharing in epidemiological research — with an emphasis on the practical and situated experiences involved in data sharing.\nThe CITF is a “data harmonization” initiative, which entails coordinating a systematic effort to align the information contained in datasets collected by distributed teams of epidemiologists. These efforts to integrate the records collected during various discrete studies are motivated by a desire to establish larger integrated datasets bearing greater statistical power and that facilitate comparison across cohorts. However, epidemiologists must reckon with the diversity of minor variations in data collection procedures, as well as ethico-legal concerns relating to the sharing of individual health records pertaining to human research subjects across numerous institutional and regional jurisdictions.\nAs a scholar of scientific practice, with a primary interest in data-sharing and the formation of information commons, data harmonization represents a fascinating mechanism through which scientists derive technical, administrative, social and epistemic frameworks to enhance the value of their collective endeavours in response to disciplinary needs, warrants, desires and expectations. This study therefore articulates the motivations for doing data harmonization, identifies how value is ascertained, and describes the strategies employed to achieve the desired goals — including perceived and actual challenges, setbacks, opportunities, realizations, and lessons learned.\nThis relates to my previous work that (a) explores tensions that arise when attempting to establish information commons in archaeology, specifically relating to inability to cope with a superficial perception of data’s stability and an intuitive understanding of their situated nature; and that (b) investigates how the open science movement attempts (and fails) to reshape practices relating to data sharing, integration and reuse. I continue in my approach that frames data-sharing — whether it occurs in relatively “closed” curcumstances between close colleagues, or as mediated by open data platforms among strangers — as comprising a series of collaborative commitments that govern who may contribute to and obtain value from the information commons, and in what ways.", "crumbs": [ "Context" ] diff --git a/sitemap.xml b/sitemap.xml index e8bdf31..00c2355 100644 --- a/sitemap.xml +++ b/sitemap.xml @@ -38,7 +38,7 @@ https://zackbatist.info/CITF-Postdoc/context.html - 2025-01-31T16:38:01.350Z + 2025-01-31T16:51:55.950Z https://zackbatist.info/CITF-Postdoc/case-selection.html