feat(slack): pass trusted actor context to concierge#158
Conversation
Review PromptPlease review this pull request and provide feedback on:
Be constructive and helpful in your feedback. Specific rules for this codebase: General rules
PII in Logs - HIGH PRIORITYFlag any code that logs user PII (Personally Identifiable Information). This is a critical security and compliance issue. Check for and reject:
Require instead:
Example violations to flag: logger.info(f"User {user.email} logged in") # BAD
logging.warning(f"Failed for {body.email}") # BAD
print(f"Contact sent: {data}") # BAD if data contains email
discord_message += f"Email: {user.email}" # BADCorrect patterns: logger.info(f"User auth_id={user.auth_id} logged in") # GOOD
logger.warning("Failed login", {"auth_id": user.auth_id}) # GOODi18n rules
|
👍 GitRank PR AnalysisScore: 20 points
Eligibility Checks
Impact SummaryThis PR enables the Slack gateway to pass trusted actor context metadata to the concierge runtime, allowing downstream services to create zeno instances for users like zenobot. The implementation prepends a JSON-encoded trusted context block containing workspace, actor, channel, and conversation identifiers to user prompts. The change is well-tested with comprehensive test coverage for both the new prompt shape and existing retry/deduplication logic. Analysis DetailsComponent Classification: This PR affects the Slack integration gateway and concierge communication layer, which doesn't map to a specific component in the provided table. Classified as OTHER since it's a cross-cutting integration feature. Severity Justification: Classified as P2 (Medium) because this is a functional enhancement enabling new provisioning capabilities (zenobot instance creation via spz) rather than fixing a critical bug or security issue. It has moderate impact on downstream provisioning but includes proper safeguards through trusted context metadata. Eligibility Notes: Issue: False - no referenced issue/bug report, this is a feature enhancement. Fix_implementation: True - code changes align with PR description of prepending trusted metadata. PR_linked: True - clear TL;DR, summary, and review focus provided. Tests: True - PR adds 56 lines of new test cases and modifies existing tests. Tests_required: True - this is a new feature affecting business logic (prompt construction and downstream provisioning), requiring comprehensive test coverage to ensure the trusted context contract is properly maintained. Analyzed by GitRank 🤖 |
TL;DR
Concierge should be able to create a zeno instance using spz for users like zenobot.
Summary
Review focus
Test plan
go test .inintegrations/slack-gateway