Refactor UI to components #498
Conversation
- Introduce reusable Alpine.js components for multi-stage operations and MQTT connection testing - Create `multiStageOperation.js` and `mqttTester.js` for handling complex, streaming API interactions - Refactor MQTT settings page to use new multi-stage operation component - Improve error handling, progress tracking, and user feedback for complex operations - Remove redundant inline JavaScript from integration settings page
- Introduce new reusable HTML template components for settings sections - Add `noteField`, `numberField`, `selectField`, and `sectionHeader` templates - Refactor integration, MQTT, telemetry, and weather settings to use new components - Improve accessibility with ARIA attributes and semantic HTML structure - Standardize Alpine.js data management and change tracking across settings sections
- Add ARIA attributes and semantic HTML structure to filter settings sections - Refactor privacy and dog bark filter sections using new reusable components - Improve section headers, tooltips, and form input styling - Enhance Alpine.js data management and change tracking - Standardize layout and accessibility across filter settings
- Remove unnecessary margin class from dog bark species list container - Maintain consistent spacing with other filter settings sections
- Introduce new JavaScript utility functions and mixins for species list management - Create reusable Alpine.js components for species input and list interactions - Add new HTML templates for species list and action menu components - Enhance species settings pages with modular, interactive species management - Improve prediction filtering, duplicate prevention, and change tracking - Standardize species list editing and removal across different settings sections
- Refactor `speciesComponentMixin.js` to provide a more flexible and generic species list management approach - Add dynamic list type handling, improved prediction filtering, and more robust editing methods - Update `speciesUtils.js` with generalized utility functions for species list operations - Modify species settings pages to leverage the new mixin and utility functions - Improve change tracking, input validation, and component interoperability
- Enhance species list components to support multiple list types - Update `speciesComponentMixin.js` to handle list type filtering - Modify species list templates to include optional list type parameter - Add list type differentiation for edit and remove actions in species settings pages - Improve component flexibility and event handling for different species lists
- Add support for save and cancel buttons in species list action menu - Update `speciesComponentMixin.js` to handle optional event dispatching - Modify species list template to support new save/cancel events - Improve edit mode UI with dedicated save and cancel buttons - Implement list type filtering for edit and cancel actions - Add input blur functionality to reset edit state cleanly
- Replace hardcoded section headers with reusable `sectionHeader` template - Add responsive grid layout to filter and integration settings sections - Improve consistency and modularity of settings page components - Enhance layout with grid classes for better responsiveness
- Replace hardcoded form controls with new template components like `checkbox`, `textField`, `selectField`, and `numberField` - Simplify audio settings HTML by leveraging template-based form generation - Improve consistency and modularity of audio settings page components - Maintain existing input validation and Alpine.js event handling logic - Enhance readability and reduce code duplication in audio settings section
WalkthroughThis pull request introduces several new components, mixins, and utility functions while refactoring existing code. A new Alpine.js component for multi-stage operations has been added along with a species management mixin and related utility functions. Several HTML templates have been created or updated for UI elements in settings pages, and legacy styles have been removed or replaced in the CSS. Additionally, a Go function for including templates has been introduced, and various settings pages have been refactored to use templating for improved modularity and accessibility. Changes
Sequence Diagram(s)sequenceDiagram
participant U as User
participant M as MultiStageOperation Component
participant API as Server API
U->>M: Clicks the operation button
M->>API: Sends POST request with payload
API-->>M: Streams progress updates
M->>M: Updates stage statuses (running, success, error)
M->>U: Displays final operation result and messages
sequenceDiagram
participant U as User
participant SC as Species Component
participant SU as Species Utils/Mixin
U->>SC: Enters species name in input
SC->>SU: Calls updateSpeciesPredictions(input)
SU-->>SC: Returns filtered prediction list
U->>SC: Selects and confirms species entry
SC->>SU: Calls addSpeciesToList(newSpecies)
SU-->>SC: Updates species list and resets input
Poem
Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media? 🪧 TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (Invoked using PR comments)
Other keywords and placeholders
CodeRabbit Configuration File (
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 2
🧹 Nitpick comments (22)
views/components/noteField.html (1)
1-6: Clean component implementation, but consider removing redundant margin.The noteField component correctly implements conditional display with Alpine.js, but there's redundant margin styling.
{{define "noteField"}} <div x-show="{{.condition}}" class="mt-4"> - <div class="mt-4 p-4 bg-base-200 rounded-lg text-sm" x-html="`{{.content}}`"> + <div class="p-4 bg-base-200 rounded-lg text-sm" x-html="`{{.content}}`"> </div> </div> {{end}}views/components/selectField.html (1)
5-10: Add keyboard accessibility to the help icon.The help icon is currently only accessible via mouse events. Adding keyboard events would improve accessibility.
<span class="help-icon" @mouseenter="showTooltip = '{{.id}}'" @mouseleave="showTooltip = null" + @keydown.enter="showTooltip = showTooltip === '{{.id}}' ? null : '{{.id}}'" + @keydown.space.prevent="showTooltip = showTooltip === '{{.id}}' ? null : '{{.id}}'" aria-label="Show help for {{.label}}" role="button" tabindex="0">ⓘ</span>views/components/sectionHeader.html (1)
4-4: Add visual indication for collapsible section.The label doesn't visually indicate that it controls a collapsible section. Consider adding an icon to provide a visual cue.
- <label for="{{.id}}SettingsOpen" class="cursor-pointer" aria-label="{{.title}} Settings">{{.title}}</label> + <label for="{{.id}}SettingsOpen" class="cursor-pointer flex items-center" aria-label="{{.title}} Settings"> + <span>{{.title}}</span> + <svg class="w-4 h-4 ml-2" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" viewBox="0 0 24 24" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"> + <path stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" stroke-width="2" d="M19 9l-7 7-7-7"></path> + </svg> + </label>views/components/numberField.html (2)
5-10: Add keyboard accessibility to the help icon.Similar to the selectField component, the help icon should support keyboard interactions for better accessibility.
<span class="help-icon" @mouseenter="showTooltip = '{{.id}}'" @mouseleave="showTooltip = null" + @keydown.enter="showTooltip = showTooltip === '{{.id}}' ? null : '{{.id}}'" + @keydown.space.prevent="showTooltip = showTooltip === '{{.id}}' ? null : '{{.id}}'" aria-label="Show help for {{.label}}" role="button" tabindex="0">ⓘ</span>
1-31: Consider implementing a common base template for form fields.This component shares significant structure with selectField.html. Consider creating a base form field template that both components could extend to reduce duplication.
You could create a base template with shared structure and use template composition to specialize for different input types.
internal/httpcontroller/template_functions.go (2)
68-75: Add documentation comment for the new includeTemplate function.The function is well-implemented but lacks a documentation comment explaining its purpose and usage.
+ // includeTemplate renders a template with the given name and data, + // returning the rendered content as template.HTML. + // This allows templates to include other templates with custom data. + // Parameters: + // - name: Name of the template to include + // - data: Data to pass to the template + // Returns: + // - Rendered template as template.HTML + // - Error if template rendering fails "includeTemplate": func(name string, data interface{}) (template.HTML, error) { var buf bytes.Buffer err := s.Echo.Renderer.(*TemplateRenderer).templates.ExecuteTemplate(&buf, name, data) if err != nil { return "", err } return template.HTML(buf.String()), nil },
71-73: Improve error handling with more context.When template execution fails, the error message doesn't provide context about which template failed.
err := s.Echo.Renderer.(*TemplateRenderer).templates.ExecuteTemplate(&buf, name, data) if err != nil { - return "", err + return "", fmt.Errorf("failed to include template %q: %w", name, err) }views/components/settingsSection.html (1)
17-20: Toggle Control via Checkbox
The checkbox input toggles the open state usingx-on:change="{{.id}}SettingsOpen = !{{.id}}SettingsOpen". This approach is acceptable; however, double-check that the dynamic variable name works as expected in the Alpine context.views/elements/speciesListActionMenu.html (1)
5-34: Dynamic Positioning Logic
TheupdatePositionmethod computes available space above and below the button and then adjusts the dropdown menu’s CSS styles (position, top, bottom, left, right) accordingly. This ensures the menu is optimally positioned within the viewport.
- Suggestion: Consider adding error handling or logging if the references to
menuorbuttonare missing.views/components/multiStageOperation.html (2)
24-26: Consider factoring out repeated logic for tooltips.Lines 24–26 duplicate the same ternary expression for both
titleandaria-label, which can introduce redundancy and maintenance overhead. You could extract this logic into an Alpine method or a computed property for clarity.
37-39: Add additional ARIA attributes or labels for improved accessibility.The element at lines 37–39 includes
role="region"andaria-live="polite", which is excellent for screen readers. Consider adding anaria-labelledbyoraria-describedbyreferencing a heading or block of text that more explicitly announces the context of these results to improve accessibility for visually impaired users.assets/js/components/multiStageOperation.js (2)
32-60: Ensure start method prevents concurrent invocations and race conditions.If users click the button multiple times before the first operation initializes or completes, it could lead to overlapping fetch calls. Consider adding logic to guard against multiple
start()calls whenisRunningis already true, or queue subsequent calls after the current operation completes.
187-197: Clarify the completeness condition for complex operations.Currently,
isCompleteSuccess()requires all stages to be successful and checks the final stage’s presence in the results. If your operation has optional or parallel stages, this logic may incorrectly mark the operation as incomplete. Confirm that all real-world usage aligns with strictly sequential or required stages.assets/js/components/speciesComponentMixin.js (7)
28-36: Use optional chaining for safer property access.Multiple conditionals in the
getSpeciesListmethod could be simplified with optional chaining.Apply this change to improve code readability:
getSpeciesList() { // Default implementation for species settings structure - if (this.speciesSettings && this.speciesSettings[listType]) { - return this.speciesSettings[listType]; - } - // Dog bark filter structure - else if (this.dogBarkFilter && this.dogBarkFilter.species) { - return this.dogBarkFilter.species; - } + // Default implementation for species settings structure + if (this.speciesSettings?.[listType]) { + return this.speciesSettings[listType]; + } + // Dog bark filter structure + else if (this.dogBarkFilter?.species) { + return this.dogBarkFilter.species; + } // Fallback empty array return []; },🧰 Tools
🪛 Biome (1.9.4)
[error] 28-28: Change to an optional chain.
Unsafe fix: Change to an optional chain.
(lint/complexity/useOptionalChain)
[error] 32-32: Change to an optional chain.
Unsafe fix: Change to an optional chain.
(lint/complexity/useOptionalChain)
44-61: Use optional chaining for safer property access.Similar to the previous comment, the
setSpeciesListmethod could benefit from optional chaining.Apply this change to improve code readability:
setSpeciesList(newList) { // Default implementation for species settings structure - if (this.speciesSettings && this.speciesSettings[listType]) { + if (this.speciesSettings?.[listType]) { this.speciesSettings[listType] = newList; } // Dog bark filter structure else if (this.dogBarkFilter) { this.dogBarkFilter.species = newList; } // Mark changes this.hasChanges = true; // Allow components to implement additional logic after modifications - if (typeof this.afterModification === 'function') { + if (typeof this.afterModification === 'function') { this.afterModification(); } },🧰 Tools
🪛 Biome (1.9.4)
[error] 46-46: Change to an optional chain.
Unsafe fix: Change to an optional chain.
(lint/complexity/useOptionalChain)
78-106: Improve prediction filtering logic.The
updatePredictionsmethod could be more efficient by extracting constants outside of the filter loop.Consider refactoring for better performance:
updatePredictions(input, specificListType) { if (!input) { this.predictions = []; return; } const targetListType = specificListType || listType; // Get the appropriate source list based on list type const sourceList = this.getSourceList(targetListType); if (!sourceList || sourceList.length === 0) { this.predictions = []; return; } // Get the current species list const existingSpecies = this.getSpeciesList(); // Filter out species that are already in the list (case insensitive) const existingSpeciesLower = existingSpecies.map(s => s.toLowerCase()); const inputLower = input.toLowerCase(); + // Filter and limit to 5 suggestions this.predictions = sourceList .filter(species => { const speciesLower = species.toLowerCase(); - return speciesLower.includes(inputLower) && !existingSpeciesLower.includes(speciesLower); + // First check if species includes the input text + if (!speciesLower.includes(inputLower)) { + return false; + } + // Then check it's not already in the list + return !existingSpeciesLower.includes(speciesLower); }) .slice(0, 5); // limit to 5 suggestions },
209-221: Use optional chaining for event detail access.The event handling could be simplified with optional chaining.
Apply this change for better readability:
startEdit(event) { // Extract index from event or use directly if it's a number let index; let eventListType; if (typeof event === 'object') { // If it's an event from the window event dispatch - if (event.detail) { - index = event.detail.index; - eventListType = event.detail.listType; - } + if (event?.detail) { + index = event.detail.index; + eventListType = event.detail.listType; + } } else { // If it's a direct index index = event; }
240-246: Use optional chaining for event detail access.Similarly, optional chaining should be used in the
saveEditmethod.Apply this change for consistency:
saveEdit(event) { // Handle event from dispatch if provided - if (event && event.detail) { + if (event?.detail) { const eventListType = event.detail.listType; // Check if the list type matches if (eventListType && eventListType !== listType) { return; // Skip if list types don't match } }🧰 Tools
🪛 Biome (1.9.4)
[error] 240-240: Change to an optional chain.
Unsafe fix: Change to an optional chain.
(lint/complexity/useOptionalChain)
273-279: Use optional chaining for event detail access.Similarly, optional chaining should be used in the
cancelEditmethod.Apply this change for consistency:
cancelEdit(event) { // Handle event from dispatch if provided - if (event && event.detail) { + if (event?.detail) { const eventListType = event.detail.listType; // Check if the list type matches if (eventListType && eventListType !== listType) { return; // Skip if list types don't match } }🧰 Tools
🪛 Biome (1.9.4)
[error] 273-273: Change to an optional chain.
Unsafe fix: Change to an optional chain.
(lint/complexity/useOptionalChain)
87-91: Enhance null checking.The current check uses truthiness which might not catch empty arrays.
Consider a more explicit check for arrays:
// Get the appropriate source list based on list type const sourceList = this.getSourceList(targetListType); -if (!sourceList || sourceList.length === 0) { +if (!Array.isArray(sourceList) || sourceList.length === 0) { this.predictions = []; return; }assets/js/components/speciesUtils.js (2)
77-112: Consider simplifying the index extraction logic.The index extraction logic is duplicated across multiple functions. Consider extracting this into a separate utility function to reduce code duplication.
+/** + * Extracts an index from an event or returns the direct index + * @param {number|Event} indexOrEvent - The index or event containing the index + * @returns {number|undefined} - The extracted index or undefined + */ +function extractIndexFromEvent(indexOrEvent) { + if (typeof indexOrEvent === 'object') { + // If it's an event from the window event dispatch + if (indexOrEvent.detail && indexOrEvent.detail.index !== undefined) { + return indexOrEvent.detail.index; + } + } else { + // If it's a direct index + return indexOrEvent; + } + return undefined; +} function removeSpeciesFromList(indexOrEvent, speciesList, setSpeciesList, setHasChanges = null) { - // Extract index from event or use directly if it's a number - let index; - if (typeof indexOrEvent === 'object') { - // If it's an event from the window event dispatch - if (indexOrEvent.detail && indexOrEvent.detail.index !== undefined) { - index = indexOrEvent.detail.index; - } - } else { - // If it's a direct index - index = indexOrEvent; - } + const index = extractIndexFromEvent(indexOrEvent); if (index === undefined) { return speciesList; }
114-140: Use the same index extraction logic here too.This function duplicates the same index extraction logic from
removeSpeciesFromList. Use the suggested utility function here as well.function startEditSpecies(indexOrEvent, speciesList, setEditIndex, setEditSpecies, setShowEditSpecies) { - // Extract index from event or use directly if it's a number - let index; - if (typeof indexOrEvent === 'object') { - // If it's an event from the window event dispatch - if (indexOrEvent.detail && indexOrEvent.detail.index !== undefined) { - index = indexOrEvent.detail.index; - } - } else { - // If it's a direct index - index = indexOrEvent; - } + const index = extractIndexFromEvent(indexOrEvent); if (index !== undefined && speciesList[index]) { setEditIndex(index); setEditSpecies(speciesList[index]); setShowEditSpecies(true); } }
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (24)
assets/js/components/multiStageOperation.js(1 hunks)assets/js/components/speciesComponentMixin.js(1 hunks)assets/js/components/speciesUtils.js(1 hunks)assets/tailwind.css(3 hunks)internal/httpcontroller/template_functions.go(2 hunks)views/components/checkbox.html(1 hunks)views/components/hostField.html(1 hunks)views/components/multiStageOperation.html(1 hunks)views/components/noteField.html(1 hunks)views/components/numberField.html(1 hunks)views/components/passwordField.html(1 hunks)views/components/sectionHeader.html(1 hunks)views/components/selectField.html(1 hunks)views/components/settingsSection.html(1 hunks)views/components/speciesInput.html(1 hunks)views/components/speciesList.html(1 hunks)views/components/speciesListActionMenu.html(1 hunks)views/components/textField.html(1 hunks)views/elements/speciesListActionMenu.html(1 hunks)views/pages/settings/audioSettings.html(4 hunks)views/pages/settings/filtersSettings.html(3 hunks)views/pages/settings/integrationSettings.html(6 hunks)views/pages/settings/settingsBase.html(3 hunks)views/pages/settings/speciesSettings.html(15 hunks)
✅ Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (4)
- views/components/passwordField.html
- views/components/textField.html
- views/components/hostField.html
- views/components/checkbox.html
🧰 Additional context used
🪛 Biome (1.9.4)
assets/js/components/speciesComponentMixin.js
[error] 28-28: Change to an optional chain.
Unsafe fix: Change to an optional chain.
(lint/complexity/useOptionalChain)
[error] 32-32: Change to an optional chain.
Unsafe fix: Change to an optional chain.
(lint/complexity/useOptionalChain)
[error] 46-46: Change to an optional chain.
Unsafe fix: Change to an optional chain.
(lint/complexity/useOptionalChain)
[error] 240-240: Change to an optional chain.
Unsafe fix: Change to an optional chain.
(lint/complexity/useOptionalChain)
[error] 273-273: Change to an optional chain.
Unsafe fix: Change to an optional chain.
(lint/complexity/useOptionalChain)
⏰ Context from checks skipped due to timeout of 90000ms (1)
- GitHub Check: Analyze (go)
🔇 Additional comments (73)
views/components/noteField.html (1)
3-3: Ensure content is sanitized before using x-html.Using
x-htmlwith dynamic content could potentially lead to XSS vulnerabilities if the content isn't properly sanitized before being passed to the template.Make sure that
.contentis properly sanitized on the server side before rendering.views/components/selectField.html (1)
1-32: Well-structured accessible form component.The component includes proper accessibility attributes, dynamic property handling, and responsive tooltip behavior. The structure follows best practices for form controls.
views/components/sectionHeader.html (1)
1-13: Clean implementation of section header with status indicator.The component has a well-structured layout with proper accessibility attributes, and effectively uses the
x-cloakdirective to manage the visibility of the settings changed badge.views/components/speciesListActionMenu.html (5)
1-8: Template Definition and Documentation are Clear
The file begins with a well-documented template definition. The inline comments effectively explain the purpose and expected behavior of the component.
9-18: Alpine.js Initialization and Menu Trigger
The root<div>initializes with anx-dataobject containingopen: false, which correctly controls the dropdown state. The button on lines 11–18 toggles the menu visibility using@click.prevent.stop="open = !open".
21-25: Dropdown Visibility and Accessibility Controls
The dropdown menu container properly usesx-show="open",@click.away,@keydown.escape.window, andx-cloakto manage its visibility and accessibility. This helps ensure the menu behaves as expected.
27-37: Event Dispatch for "Edit" Action
The edit option button dispatches theedit-speciesevent with{ index: index }and then closes the menu. Ensure that theindexvariable is defined in the surrounding rendering context (for example, within a loop in a parent template).
39-49: Event Dispatch for "Delete" Action
Similarly, the delete option correctly dispatches theremove-speciesevent with the species index. The closure of the dropdown is handled consistently. As with the edit action, verify thatindexis available from the parent context.views/components/settingsSection.html (4)
1-4: Template and Accessibility Attributes
The template is defined clearly and includes relevant ARIA attributes (such asrole="region"andaria-labelledby) that enhance accessibility.
5-14: Dynamic x-data Initialization with Custom Methods
Thex-dataobject is set up with dynamic properties:
{{.dataModel}}is injected directly; please ensure it outputs valid JavaScript properties.- The dynamic property
{{.id}}SettingsOpen: falserelies on the.idvalue; confirm that.idis sanitized to form a valid variable name.- The
resetChanges()method conditionally calls a custom reset function if provided.
21-24: Section Header Integration
The inclusion of thesectionHeadertemplate and the associated templated parameters properly modularizes the header.
26-31: Collapsible Content and ARIA Compliance
The collapsible content div includes proper ARIA roles and labels, promoting accessibility. The content is dynamically rendered using{{.content}}, which fits well within the design.views/elements/speciesListActionMenu.html (5)
1-7: Template Setup and Dynamic Positioning Initialization
The component template initializes with anx-datablock that includes anupdatePosition()method. The use of$nextTickto update the dropdown position after state changes is a good practice.
37-46: Conditional Action Button Display
The action button displays only when not in edit mode (using the conditionx-show="editIndex !== index"). The use ofx-refand the click handler to toggle the dropdown and update its position is clear and efficient.
48-63: Edit Mode Controls
When in edit mode (i.e.editIndex === index), the component displays Save and Cancel buttons. The event dispatches for saving and cancelling edits are correctly attached to these buttons.
65-76: Dropdown Menu Transitions and Visibility
The unordered list for the dropdown menu correctly leveragesx-show,x-ref, event handling with@click.away, and transition animations to provide a smooth user experience.
77-102: Menu Items for Editing and Removing Species
Each menu item within the dropdown dispatches the appropriate custom events (edit-speciesandremove-species) on click. The markup inside the list items is both semantically clear and visually consistent.views/components/speciesInput.html (4)
1-12: Comprehensive Usage Documentation
The initial comment block provides clear instructions regarding the expected parameters and functionality. This is very helpful for future maintenance and integration.
13-22: Responsive Layout and Input Field Setup
The outer<div>utilizes conditional classes for responsiveness. The<input>element is correctly set up with dynamicid,x-modelbinding, and event listeners (@inputand@keyup.enter).
24-28: Datalist for Suggestions
The<datalist>element is populated using an Alpine.jsx-forloop to iterate over suggestions. This provides dynamic and contextual suggestions to the user.
31-35: Customizable Add Button
The Add button reacts to click events with a dynamically provided handler ({{.onAdd}}) and displays text conditionally based on the provided parameter. This reinforces the component’s flexibility.views/components/speciesList.html (4)
1-15: Detailed Documentation and Parameter Description
The initial comment block thoroughly documents the input parameters for the species list template. This aids in understanding how to use and integrate the component.
16-24: Looping and Display Mode Handling
The template uses an Alpine.jsx-forloop to iterate over the species. The display mode condition on line 21:x-show="{{if .editIndex}}{{.editIndex}} !== index{{else}}true{{end}}"should be verified to ensure that it produces a valid JavaScript boolean expression post-templating. Similarly, the
x-textdirective on line 22 conditionally uses a custom display function if provided.
25-33: Inline Editing Input Field
When in edit mode, the template displays an<input>field bound to{{.editValue}}, with event listeners to handle saving and cancelling edits. The conditional rendering using{{if and .editMode .editValue .onSave}}is a neat way to ensure that editing is only enabled when all required parameters are provided.
35-52: Dynamic Actions and Template Inclusion
The actions section checks if a customactionTemplateis provided.
- When present, it sets up an
x-datablock with local variables and listens for custom events (edit-species,remove-species, etc.) to trigger corresponding functions.- The use of
includeTemplateto render the custom action template enhances modularity.
If no custom template is provided, a default Remove button is displayed.
Ensure that the dynamic evaluation oflistTypeand the conditional event handling produce valid expressions after templating.views/components/multiStageOperation.html (1)
113-128: Verify conditional display logic for successful completion message.Currently, the component uses
{{if .showCompletionMessage}}{{.showCompletionMessage}}{{else}}isCompleteSuccess(){{end}}to control visibility. Ensure that, when.showCompletionMessageis explicitly set tofalse, the fallback toisCompleteSuccess()does not trigger unintended displays. If your design requires strict, manual toggling, consider using a single, explicit control within the template or the Alpine component.assets/js/components/multiStageOperation.js (2)
73-82: Assess partial or incomplete data scenarios when streaming responses.The code splits on newline to parse JSON. If the server sends partial data or doesn't strictly follow line-delimited JSON, parsing errors can occur. You might want to incorporate a retry mechanism or more robust JSON framing to handle unusual stream boundaries.
106-114: Handle out-of-order stage messages with caution.When a later stage arrives before an earlier stage’s “completion” message, the logic marks previous running stages as completed. This could cause inaccurate reporting if the server messages don’t strictly flow in stage order. Confirm whether the server guarantees in-order stage messages before relying on this approach.
assets/tailwind.css (3)
5189-5192: New Utility Class.w-40Added
The new utility class.w-40 { width: 10rem; }has been added as documented in the PR summary. This class provides a convenient fixed width option for elements and aligns with the design adjustments introduced in the new UI components. Please ensure that any components relying on a 10rem width are updated to use this class consistently.
6514-6517: Responsive Utility Update:.md:w-36
The declaration of.md:w-36 { width: 9rem; }has been updated for medium screens. This change supports responsive design for components on medium-sized devices. Verify that the modifications are in line with the overall spacing and sizing scale used throughout the UI and update any documentation if necessary.
6534-6537: Addition of Responsive Flex Direction Utility:.md:flex-row
The new utility class.md:flex-row { flex-direction: row; }for medium screens enhances layout control by explicitly setting the flex direction. This is especially useful in responsive component design. Please double-check that its usage in the new Alpine.js components and templates remains consistent with the overall responsive strategy.views/pages/settings/settingsBase.html (3)
182-189: Improved response handling.Adding content type checking before parsing JSON is a good defensive programming practice. This prevents potential errors when the server returns non-JSON responses.
215-238: Enhanced component change tracking.The improved
resetComponentChangesmethod now properly resets change flags at multiple levels: main component, Alpine store, and child components. It also handles components with custom reset methods.
200-204: Improved user feedback for security setting changes.Adding a notification before page reload provides better user experience by clearly communicating what's happening.
views/pages/settings/filtersSettings.html (11)
6-8: Good addition of script dependencies.Adding script imports for species-related components is necessary for the new functionality. The version parameter ensures proper cache busting.
23-25: Added state reset functionality.The addition of the
resetChangesmethod to the privacy filter properly maintains the component's state when changes are reset.
37-40: Improved template usage.Using the template function for the section header improves code reusability and maintainability.
47-52: Enhanced component templating.Using templates for checkbox elements improves maintainability and ensures consistent styling.
60-68: Enhanced component templating.Using templates for number field elements improves maintainability and ensures consistent styling.
80-131: Good implementation of state tracking.The changes add proper state initialization, comparison, and change tracking for the Dog Bark Filter. The
initialStateproperty and related methods (checkForChanges,updateChanges, andresetChanges) provide a solid foundation for tracking changes.
98-99: Improved code reuse with mixins.Inheriting methods from the
speciesComponentMixinreduces code duplication and increases maintainability.
142-145: Improved template usage.Using templates for section headers creates consistent UI components.
201-212: Enhanced component templating.Using templates for species lists improves maintainability and ensures consistent behavior.
224-231: Enhanced component templating.Using templates for species inputs improves maintainability and ensures consistent behavior.
215-221: Good user feedback for unsaved changes.Adding an indicator for unsaved changes provides important visual feedback to users.
views/pages/settings/speciesSettings.html (12)
6-8: Good addition of script dependencies.Adding script imports for species components enables the reuse of functionality across different settings pages.
28-29: Improved code reuse with mixins.Inheriting methods from the
speciesComponentMixinreduces code duplication and increases maintainability.
62-64: Good implementation of source list selection.The override of
getSourceListproperly differentiates between include and exclude lists, making the mixin more flexible.
74-77: Improved template usage.Using templates for section headers creates consistent UI components across settings pages.
83-93: Enhanced component templating.Using templates for species lists improves maintainability and ensures consistent behavior.
97-104: Enhanced component templating.Using templates for species inputs improves maintainability and ensures consistent behavior.
127-128: Improved code reuse with mixins.Inheriting methods from the
speciesComponentMixinfor the exclude species section promotes consistency.
147-149: Simplified source list implementation.The override of
getSourceListfor the exclude section is more straightforward than the include section, as it only needs one source list.
159-162: Improved template usage.Using templates for section headers creates consistent UI components.
171-181: Enhanced component templating.Using templates for species lists ensures consistent behavior across different sections.
185-192: Enhanced component templating.Using templates for species inputs provides consistent behavior and appearance.
307-333: Improved prediction handling.The updated
updatePredictionsmethod in the custom configuration section properly filters out species that already have configurations, ensuring a better user experience.assets/js/components/speciesUtils.js (2)
8-35: Well-structured utility function for species prediction updates.The implementation for
updateSpeciesPredictionsis clean, with proper input validation and case-insensitive searching. The limiting of results to 5 suggestions is a good UI practice.
37-75: Good implementation with proper edge case handling.The
addSpeciesToListfunction correctly handles empty inputs, performs case-insensitive duplicate checks, and manages state appropriately. Returning a boolean to indicate success is a good practice for caller feedback.views/pages/settings/audioSettings.html (5)
108-111: Good use of templates for section headers.Using templates for section headers improves code modularity and consistency across the UI.
196-201: Well-structured checkbox template implementation.The checkbox template properly passes all necessary parameters including model binding, name, label, and tooltip.
366-371: Consistent template usage for checkboxes.These checkbox templates follow the same pattern as the one used for audio filters, maintaining consistency throughout the UI.
Also applies to: 375-380
383-388: Comprehensive use of form field templates.The textField, selectField, and numberField templates are used effectively with all required parameters, including complex conditions for disabled states and event handling.
Also applies to: 393-405, 410-419
450-453: Consistent template pattern in the audio retention section.The section header and form fields in the audio retention section follow the same template pattern as the previous sections, maintaining a consistent UI experience.
Also applies to: 460-470, 475-480, 485-491, 497-502
views/pages/settings/integrationSettings.html (9)
37-40: Clean implementation of component templates.The sectionHeader and checkbox templates are implemented well, providing a consistent UI pattern for the BirdWeather section.
Also applies to: 47-52
60-66: Good use of passwordField and numberField templates.The templates for password and number fields properly include all necessary attributes and validation parameters.
Also applies to: 68-77
141-144: Consistent pattern for MQTT section templates.The section header and checkbox templates follow the same pattern as in the BirdWeather section, maintaining consistency.
Also applies to: 151-156
164-193: Text field templates with proper tooltips and placeholders.These text field templates include all necessary properties and maintain visual consistency with other form fields.
196-206: Excellent use of the multiStageOperation template.The multiStageOperation template encapsulates complex logic for MQTT connection testing in a reusable component. The template includes comprehensive parameters for stage order, button states, and tooltips.
238-241: Consistent implementation in the Telemetry section.The section header and checkbox templates in the Telemetry section follow the same pattern as in previous sections.
Also applies to: 248-253
306-340: Well-structured weather provider section with conditional notes.The selectField template for weather provider selection and the noteField templates with conditional display provide a clean and informative UI. The notes provide valuable context about each weather provider option.
368-386: Good implementation of form fields for OpenWeather settings.The templates for select and text fields in the OpenWeather section are well-implemented with appropriate options and tooltips.
395-395: Include script for multiStageOperation component.The inclusion of the multiStageOperation.js script is necessary for the MQTT connection test functionality.
| /** | ||
| * Saves an edited species in a list | ||
| * @param {number} editIndex - The index of the species being edited | ||
| * @param {string} editSpecies - The new value for the species | ||
| * @param {Array} speciesList - The list containing the species to edit | ||
| * @param {function} setSpeciesList - Function to update the species list | ||
| * @param {function} setEditIndex - Function to reset the edit index | ||
| * @param {function} setEditSpecies - Function to reset the edit species value | ||
| * @param {function} setShowEditSpecies - Function to hide the edit interface | ||
| * @param {function} setHasChanges - Function to mark changes (optional) | ||
| */ | ||
| function saveEditSpecies(editIndex, editSpecies, speciesList, setSpeciesList, setEditIndex, setEditSpecies, setShowEditSpecies, setHasChanges = null) { | ||
| if (editIndex === null || editIndex < 0 || !editSpecies || !editSpecies.trim()) { | ||
| // Invalid edit state | ||
| setEditIndex(null); | ||
| setEditSpecies(''); | ||
| setShowEditSpecies(false); | ||
| return; | ||
| } | ||
|
|
||
| const trimmedValue = editSpecies.trim(); | ||
| const oldValue = speciesList[editIndex]; | ||
|
|
||
| // Only update if the value has changed | ||
| if (oldValue !== trimmedValue) { | ||
| const updatedList = [...speciesList]; | ||
| updatedList[editIndex] = trimmedValue; | ||
| setSpeciesList(updatedList); | ||
|
|
||
| // Mark changes if needed | ||
| if (setHasChanges) { | ||
| setHasChanges(true); | ||
| } | ||
| } | ||
|
|
||
| // Reset edit state | ||
| setEditIndex(null); | ||
| setEditSpecies(''); | ||
| setShowEditSpecies(false); | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Check for duplicate species name during editing.
When saving an edited species, there's no check to prevent creating a duplicate species name. This could lead to having multiple identical species in the list.
function saveEditSpecies(editIndex, editSpecies, speciesList, setSpeciesList, setEditIndex, setEditSpecies, setShowEditSpecies, setHasChanges = null) {
if (editIndex === null || editIndex < 0 || !editSpecies || !editSpecies.trim()) {
// Invalid edit state
setEditIndex(null);
setEditSpecies('');
setShowEditSpecies(false);
return;
}
const trimmedValue = editSpecies.trim();
const oldValue = speciesList[editIndex];
// Only update if the value has changed
if (oldValue !== trimmedValue) {
+ // Check if the new name would create a duplicate (excluding the current item)
+ const newSpeciesLower = trimmedValue.toLowerCase();
+ const hasDuplicate = speciesList.some((s, i) => i !== editIndex && s.toLowerCase() === newSpeciesLower);
+
+ if (hasDuplicate) {
+ // Don't update if it would create a duplicate
+ setEditIndex(null);
+ setEditSpecies('');
+ setShowEditSpecies(false);
+ return;
+ }
+
const updatedList = [...speciesList];
updatedList[editIndex] = trimmedValue;
setSpeciesList(updatedList);
// Mark changes if needed
if (setHasChanges) {
setHasChanges(true);
}
}📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| /** | |
| * Saves an edited species in a list | |
| * @param {number} editIndex - The index of the species being edited | |
| * @param {string} editSpecies - The new value for the species | |
| * @param {Array} speciesList - The list containing the species to edit | |
| * @param {function} setSpeciesList - Function to update the species list | |
| * @param {function} setEditIndex - Function to reset the edit index | |
| * @param {function} setEditSpecies - Function to reset the edit species value | |
| * @param {function} setShowEditSpecies - Function to hide the edit interface | |
| * @param {function} setHasChanges - Function to mark changes (optional) | |
| */ | |
| function saveEditSpecies(editIndex, editSpecies, speciesList, setSpeciesList, setEditIndex, setEditSpecies, setShowEditSpecies, setHasChanges = null) { | |
| if (editIndex === null || editIndex < 0 || !editSpecies || !editSpecies.trim()) { | |
| // Invalid edit state | |
| setEditIndex(null); | |
| setEditSpecies(''); | |
| setShowEditSpecies(false); | |
| return; | |
| } | |
| const trimmedValue = editSpecies.trim(); | |
| const oldValue = speciesList[editIndex]; | |
| // Only update if the value has changed | |
| if (oldValue !== trimmedValue) { | |
| const updatedList = [...speciesList]; | |
| updatedList[editIndex] = trimmedValue; | |
| setSpeciesList(updatedList); | |
| // Mark changes if needed | |
| if (setHasChanges) { | |
| setHasChanges(true); | |
| } | |
| } | |
| // Reset edit state | |
| setEditIndex(null); | |
| setEditSpecies(''); | |
| setShowEditSpecies(false); | |
| } | |
| /** | |
| * Saves an edited species in a list | |
| * @param {number} editIndex - The index of the species being edited | |
| * @param {string} editSpecies - The new value for the species | |
| * @param {Array} speciesList - The list containing the species to edit | |
| * @param {function} setSpeciesList - Function to update the species list | |
| * @param {function} setEditIndex - Function to reset the edit index | |
| * @param {function} setEditSpecies - Function to reset the edit species value | |
| * @param {function} setShowEditSpecies - Function to hide the edit interface | |
| * @param {function} setHasChanges - Function to mark changes (optional) | |
| */ | |
| function saveEditSpecies(editIndex, editSpecies, speciesList, setSpeciesList, setEditIndex, setEditSpecies, setShowEditSpecies, setHasChanges = null) { | |
| if (editIndex === null || editIndex < 0 || !editSpecies || !editSpecies.trim()) { | |
| // Invalid edit state | |
| setEditIndex(null); | |
| setEditSpecies(''); | |
| setShowEditSpecies(false); | |
| return; | |
| } | |
| const trimmedValue = editSpecies.trim(); | |
| const oldValue = speciesList[editIndex]; | |
| // Only update if the value has changed | |
| if (oldValue !== trimmedValue) { | |
| // Check if the new name would create a duplicate (excluding the current item) | |
| const newSpeciesLower = trimmedValue.toLowerCase(); | |
| const hasDuplicate = speciesList.some((s, i) => i !== editIndex && s.toLowerCase() === newSpeciesLower); | |
| if (hasDuplicate) { | |
| // Don't update if it would create a duplicate | |
| setEditIndex(null); | |
| setEditSpecies(''); | |
| setShowEditSpecies(false); | |
| return; | |
| } | |
| const updatedList = [...speciesList]; | |
| updatedList[editIndex] = trimmedValue; | |
| setSpeciesList(updatedList); | |
| // Mark changes if needed | |
| if (setHasChanges) { | |
| setHasChanges(true); | |
| } | |
| } | |
| // Reset edit state | |
| setEditIndex(null); | |
| setEditSpecies(''); | |
| setShowEditSpecies(false); | |
| } |
…emplates - Replace hardcoded form controls with new template components like `checkbox`, `textField`, `selectField`, and `numberField` - Simplify main and UI settings HTML by leveraging template-based form generation - Improve consistency and modularity of settings page components - Enhance layout with responsive grid classes - Remove commented-out and unused code sections - Add ARIA attributes and semantic HTML structure to improve accessibility
…ributes - Add min, max, and step attributes to number input fields in main settings page - Improve input validation and user experience for numeric settings - Enhance consistency with other settings pages using number field templates - Refactor database type selection to use the `selectField` template - Remove hardcoded database type selection in favor of template-based approach
- Replace hardcoded RTSP transport protocol selection with `selectField` template - Simplify audio settings HTML by leveraging template-based form generation - Update API endpoint for fetching audio devices from `/settings/audio/get` to `/api/v1/settings/audio/get` - Maintain existing Alpine.js event handling and input validation logic
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 1
🧹 Nitpick comments (4)
assets/tailwind.css (1)
1-100: Overall Impact of Legacy Class Removals
The update removes the legacy utility classes.card-actions,.bottom-full, and.hover:underline. This change may affect any components or HTML templates that previously depended on these classes for layout or styling. Please verify that all dependent components (such as those referenced in the PR objectives: multi-stage operation components and species lists) have been updated appropriately to reflect these removals.views/pages/settings/mainSettings.html (3)
42-48: Node Name Input Field
ThetextFieldtemplate is applied correctly to bindmain.namewith an appropriate label and tooltip. Ensure that any client-side validation (if needed) is implemented consistently across similar fields.
150-158: BirdNET Threads Field
The number field for "TensorFlow CPU Threads" is well defined. Consider adding a brief inline note (in the tooltip or help text) to clarify that a value of "0" means all available threads are used.
200-236: Dynamic Threshold Options Group
The group of number fields for dynamic threshold settings (trigger, minimum, and expire time) is well structured with clear constraints and tooltips. It might be beneficial to consider an inline validation that ensures the trigger value is logically above the minimum threshold.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (4)
assets/tailwind.css(3 hunks)views/components/selectField.html(1 hunks)views/pages/settings/integrationSettings.html(5 hunks)views/pages/settings/mainSettings.html(5 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (1)
- views/components/selectField.html
⏰ Context from checks skipped due to timeout of 90000ms (3)
- GitHub Check: unit-tests
- GitHub Check: Analyze (javascript-typescript)
- GitHub Check: Analyze (go)
🔇 Additional comments (45)
assets/tailwind.css (3)
5189-5191: New Utility Class Added:.w-40
A new utility class.w-40is introduced that sets the width to 10rem. Ensure that this size aligns with the design requirements and is consistent with your overall spacing and sizing system.
6514-6516: New Responsive Class Added:.md\:w-36
The class.md\:w-36applies a width of 9rem on medium-sized screens. Please confirm that this value integrates well with your responsive design breakpoints and that similar width classes follow a consistent naming convention.
6530-6533: New Responsive Flex Utility:.md\:flex-row
The new.md\:flex-rowclass explicitly setsflex-direction: rowfor medium-sized screens. This utility improves layout control in responsive designs. Verify that this matches the intended behavior in the refactored UI components.views/pages/settings/mainSettings.html (26)
26-30: Node Settings – Section Header Template
The use of the templatedsectionHeaderfor the Node Settings is well structured. The dictionary keys ("id","title","description") are used consistently, which improves modularity and maintainability.
96-100: BirdNET Settings – Section Header Template
The header for the BirdNET Settings now clearly states its purpose. The title and description are concise and effective.
112-120: BirdNET Sensitivity Field
ThenumberFieldfor sensitivity is configured with a defined range (0.5 to 1.5) and step value, which is clear. Double-check that these numeric limits reflect the valid input range for the AI model.
122-130: BirdNET Threshold Field
The threshold field is set up with precise min, max, and step values. The tooltip text could perhaps clarify that the valid input is expected as a decimal fraction (e.g. 0.01 to 0.99).
132-140: BirdNET Overlap Field
The configuration for the overlap field is correct with its numerical constraints. No issues found.
142-148: BirdNET Locale Selection Field
The select field for locale is efficiently rendered using theselectFieldtemplate. Ensure the variable.Localesis always supplied in the template context to prevent runtime errors.
163-164: Custom BirdNET Classifier – Section Title
A clear header (“Custom BirdNET Classifier”) was introduced, improving the logical grouping of related settings.
165-177: BirdNET Model Path Field
The text field for the model path clearly indicates that a restart is required, and the tooltip is informative. This helps users understand the impact of their changes.
178-184: BirdNET Label Path Field
Similarly, the label path field is concise and communicates its restart requirement.
192-197: Dynamic Threshold Enabled Checkbox
The checkbox for enabling dynamic thresholds is implemented using the template with proper binding and a descriptive tooltip. Ensure that the “BirdNET-Go specific feature” note is clearly documented for end users.
239-239: Range Filter – Section Title
The header for the Range Filter is styled appropriately to delineate this section from others.
242-247: Range Filter Container
The grid container for range filter settings is properly set up in the template. The ARIA roles and labels help maintain accessibility.
272-280: Latitude Input Field
The latitude field is correctly configured with limits from –90.0 to 90.0 and an appropriate step size. The tooltip clearly indicates its usage.
283-291: Longitude Input Field
The longitude field mirrors the latitude field’s configuration and is set up accurately with its defined constraints.
293-304: Range Filter Model Selection
This select field allows users to choose between the “legacy” and “latest” range filter models. The use of a dictionary for options enhances readability.
306-314: Range Filter Threshold Field
The threshold field is precisely defined with a clear range and step. The tooltip explains the purpose well, ensuring users understand its effect.
406-410: Database Settings – Section Header Template
Introducing a templated header for the Database Settings aligns with the refactoring objective, making the UI more modular.
418-424: Database Type Selection
The select field for choosing the database (SQLite or MySQL) is clear and concise. This helps standardize user input.
429-432: SQLite Recommendation Note
The note reminding users that SQLite is generally recommended is a useful addition. Verify that similar guidance is provided elsewhere if needed.
434-447: SQLite Output Settings
The text field for the SQLite database path is implemented clearly. All necessary attributes (placeholder, label, tooltip) are present to guide the user.
451-503: MySQL Output Settings
The MySQL configuration fields (host, port, username, password, database) are neatly templated. Special attention should be paid to the password field to ensure it is properly masked. Overall, the consistent use of the templates enhances clarity and reusability.
532-536: User Interface Settings – Section Header Template
The section header for UI Settings is clear and its use of thesectionHeadertemplate reinforces consistency across the settings pages.
545-549: Dashboard Options Container
The grid layout for the Dashboard settings is correctly structured. This improves the visual presentation and organization of the settings.
551-560: Daily Summary Species Limit Field
The number field for setting the maximum species count in the daily summary table is well configured with a sensible range.
564-570: Dashboard Thumbnails – Daily Summary Checkbox
The templated checkbox for displaying thumbnails in the daily summary table is clear and functional.
572-579: Dashboard Thumbnails – Recent Detections Checkbox
Likewise, the checkbox for recent detections thumbnails follows the same clear pattern.views/pages/settings/integrationSettings.html (16)
32-35: BirdWeather – Toggle Control for Section Visibility
The input element now includes anx-on:changehandler and ARIA attributes (aria-controlsandaria-expanded), which helps with accessibility.
37-40: BirdWeather – Section Header Template
ThesectionHeadertemplate is used effectively to render the BirdWeather settings header with a descriptive title and explanation.
47-53: BirdWeather – Enable Uploads Checkbox
The checkbox for enabling BirdWeather uploads is templated cleanly. The naming and tooltip provide clear guidance to the user.
54-77: BirdWeather – Additional Settings Fields
Within the container that is conditionally shown (when uploads are enabled), the password field for the BirdWeather token and the number field for upload threshold are implemented correctly using the respective templates. Ensure that the password field masks the token appropriately.
141-145: MQTT – Section Header Template
The MQTT settings area now benefits from a templated header that clearly states its purpose.
151-157: MQTT – Enable Integration Checkbox
The templated checkbox for enabling MQTT integration is concise and includes a useful tooltip.
164-178: MQTT – Connection Settings Fields
The templated text fields for entering the MQTT broker URL, topic, and username are implemented in a clear and organized fashion.
187-194: MQTT – Password Field
The MQTT password field uses thepasswordFieldtemplate appropriately. Confirm that no sensitive data is exposed in the frontend and that proper masking is enforced.
232-236: Telemetry – Toggle Control for Section Visibility
The input checkbox for controlling the visibility of the Telemetry settings now includes proper ARIA attributes, supporting accessibility.
238-242: Telemetry – Section Header Template
The Telemetry section header is rendered via the templated component, clearly presenting its title and description.
243-247: Telemetry – Enable Integration Checkbox
The checkbox for enabling Telemetry is implemented similarly to the other sections, ensuring consistent UI behavior.
300-304: Weather – Toggle Control for Section Visibility
The weather settings section now features an input element with the appropriatex-on:changehandler and ARIA attributes, which is beneficial for both interactivity and accessibility.
306-310: Weather – Section Header Template
ThesectionHeadertemplate is employed to display the Weather settings header with clear text and description.
316-323: Weather – Provider Selection and Notes
The weather provider selection is implemented using theselectFieldtemplate, followed by conditionalnoteFieldtemplates that display provider-specific informational notes. This modular approach simplifies future updates and maintenance.
347-385: Weather – OpenWeather Specific Settings
The OpenWeather configuration is neatly encapsulated in a grid layout using templated fields (passwordField for the API key, textField for the endpoint, selectField for units, and textField for language). The tooltips are concise and informative.
392-394: Alpine.js Component Script Inclusion
Including themultiStageOperation.jsscript at the end is appropriate for ensuring the new component functionality is available. Verify that the script is loaded only once and does not conflict with other components.
| {{template "multiStageOperation" dict | ||
| "operationName" "MQTT Connection Test" | ||
| "apiEndpoint" "/api/v1/mqtt/test" | ||
| "stageOrder" "['Starting Test', 'Service Check', 'Service Start', 'DNS Resolution', 'TCP Connection', 'MQTT Connection', 'Message Publishing']" | ||
| "buttonText" "Test MQTT Connection" | ||
| "buttonLoadingText" "Testing..." | ||
| "buttonDisabledCondition" "!mqtt.enabled || !mqtt.broker || isRunning" | ||
| "buttonTooltipMap" "!mqtt.enabled ? 'MQTT must be enabled to test' : !mqtt.broker ? 'MQTT broker must be specified' : isRunning ? 'Test in progress...' : 'Test MQTT connection'" | ||
| "payload" "{enabled: mqtt.enabled, broker: mqtt.broker, topic: mqtt.topic, username: mqtt.username, password: mqtt.password}" | ||
| "completionMessage" "Please remember to save settings to apply the changes permanently." | ||
| }} |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
MQTT – Multi-Stage Operation Component for Connection Testing
The multi-stage operation component is a notable enhancement for testing the MQTT connection. However, note that the buttonDisabledCondition uses isRunning, which is not defined in the current x-data for MQTT. It is recommended to either add an isRunning property or update the condition to use the existing mqtt.isTesting flag. For example:
- "buttonDisabledCondition" "!mqtt.enabled || !mqtt.broker || isRunning"
+ "buttonDisabledCondition" "!mqtt.enabled || !mqtt.broker || mqtt.isTesting"This change will ensure the button state is managed correctly during the test.
📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| {{template "multiStageOperation" dict | |
| "operationName" "MQTT Connection Test" | |
| "apiEndpoint" "/api/v1/mqtt/test" | |
| "stageOrder" "['Starting Test', 'Service Check', 'Service Start', 'DNS Resolution', 'TCP Connection', 'MQTT Connection', 'Message Publishing']" | |
| "buttonText" "Test MQTT Connection" | |
| "buttonLoadingText" "Testing..." | |
| "buttonDisabledCondition" "!mqtt.enabled || !mqtt.broker || isRunning" | |
| "buttonTooltipMap" "!mqtt.enabled ? 'MQTT must be enabled to test' : !mqtt.broker ? 'MQTT broker must be specified' : isRunning ? 'Test in progress...' : 'Test MQTT connection'" | |
| "payload" "{enabled: mqtt.enabled, broker: mqtt.broker, topic: mqtt.topic, username: mqtt.username, password: mqtt.password}" | |
| "completionMessage" "Please remember to save settings to apply the changes permanently." | |
| }} | |
| {{template "multiStageOperation" dict | |
| "operationName" "MQTT Connection Test" | |
| "apiEndpoint" "/api/v1/mqtt/test" | |
| "stageOrder" "['Starting Test', 'Service Check', 'Service Start', 'DNS Resolution', 'TCP Connection', 'MQTT Connection', 'Message Publishing']" | |
| "buttonText" "Test MQTT Connection" | |
| "buttonLoadingText" "Testing..." | |
| - "buttonDisabledCondition" "!mqtt.enabled || !mqtt.broker || isRunning" | |
| + "buttonDisabledCondition" "!mqtt.enabled || !mqtt.broker || mqtt.isTesting" | |
| "buttonTooltipMap" "!mqtt.enabled ? 'MQTT must be enabled to test' : !mqtt.broker ? 'MQTT broker must be specified' : isRunning ? 'Test in progress...' : 'Test MQTT connection'" | |
| "payload" "{enabled: mqtt.enabled, broker: mqtt.broker, topic: mqtt.topic, username: mqtt.username, password: mqtt.password}" | |
| "completionMessage" "Please remember to save settings to apply the changes permanently." | |
| }} |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
🧹 Nitpick comments (2)
views/pages/settings/audioSettings.html (2)
407-416: Audio Export Bitrate Field:
The bitrate field now includes inline event logic to enforce input formatting (ensuring the value ends with "k" and falls within a valid range). While effective, consider abstracting this logic into a helper function if it grows more complex.
483-489: Max Usage Field:
The max usage field includes inline logic to append a '%' symbol if missing, providing immediate feedback. Although functional, consider adding further input validation or error messaging for non-numeric inputs to enhance usability.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (1)
views/pages/settings/audioSettings.html(6 hunks)
🔇 Additional comments (13)
views/pages/settings/audioSettings.html (13)
63-69: API Endpoint Update:
The fetch call now uses/api/v1/settings/audio/get, which aligns with our API versioning approach. Please verify that the backend endpoint is updated accordingly and that error handling remains robust.
108-112: Section Header Template (Audio Capture):
Rendering the audio capture header using thesectionHeadertemplate improves maintainability and consistency. Confirm that the template correctly handles and displays the passed properties (id, title, description).
149-158: RTSP Transport Field Template:
Converting the RTSP transport selection to use a template streamlines the UI code. Verify that the options provided (tcpandudp) are rendered correctly and that the data binding foraudioCapture.rtsp.transportfunctions as intended.
193-198: Audio Filters Toggle Template:
The "Enable Audio Equalizer" checkbox is now rendered via a template, reducing duplication and ensuring stylistic uniformity. Double-check that the binding toaudioCapture.equalizer.enabledcorrectly toggles the feature.
355-358: Audio Export Section Header:
The export settings header now leverages thesectionHeadertemplate, which promotes reusability and consistency across different settings pages. Make sure that the provided attributes (id, title, description) integrate well with the overall UI design.
362-368: Audio Export Enable Checkbox:
The checkbox for enabling audio export is now template-based, maintaining consistency with other UI elements. Verify that the model binding (audioExport.enabled) accurately reflects the state changes in the UI.
371-378: Audio Export Debug Checkbox:
Implementing the "Enable Debug Mode" checkbox using a template reduces redundancy. Ensure that togglingaudioExport.debugproperly triggers the associated debug behavior within the export functionality.
380-386: Audio Export Path Field:
The audio export path is now rendered as a templated text field, aiding in a uniform interface. Confirm that user inputs for the export path are handled correctly and that backend validations are in place if necessary.
390-403: Audio Export Type Field:
Switching the export type selection to a template-basedselectFieldenhances modularity. Verify that the options provided (WAV, FLAC, AAC, Opus, MP3) are accurate and that users receive clear guidance from the tooltip.
446-449: Audio Retention Section Header:
Utilizing thesectionHeadertemplate for the audio retention section enhances consistency with the rest of the settings pages. Ensure that the header’s look and feel align with the other sections.
457-467: Retention Policy Field:
Rendering the retention policy dropdown via a template reduces duplication and simplifies future modifications. Confirm that the options (none,age,usage) match backend expectations.
473-478: Max Age Field:
The max age input now leverages a templated text field, improving consistency with other user inputs. Verify that the tooltip clearly explains the accepted format (e.g., "h", "d", "w", "m", "y") to end users.
494-500: Minimum Clips Field:
Using thenumberFieldtemplate for the minimum clips input ensures that only valid numeric values are accepted, which helps maintain data integrity.
…on management - Refactor species configuration section with improved editing capabilities - Add support for editing species configuration name and threshold - Implement custom action menu with edit, add action, and remove options - Enhance input validation and user experience for species configuration - Update Alpine.js components to support more flexible species management - Improve responsiveness and layout of species configuration inputs
- Extract common notification creation logic into a private `_createNotification` method - Refactor `handleNotification` to use the new private method - Improve code reusability and reduce duplication in notification management - Maintain existing notification behavior and timeout mechanism
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
🧹 Nitpick comments (5)
assets/tailwind.css (1)
5191-5193: Review of the.w-28utility classThe newly added
.w-28class sets the element’s width to7rem. This addition expands the width scale and offers a useful size option for smaller elements.Ensure that the overall spacing scale in your project is consistent and that this class will integrate well with other width utilities.
views/components/speciesListActionMenu.html (2)
96-146: Custom Menu Items SectionThe custom menu items block allows for multiple configuration options (such as
editConfigandaddAction), which is a flexible design choice. One point to verify is that the variableitem(passed in the event payload, e.g., inedit-species-configandspecies-add-action) is defined in the current context. If it is intended to be inherited from a surrounding scope, please ensure that is always available.If
itemmight be undefined at runtime, consider initializing it in the component’sx-datadeclaration or passing it explicitly.
148-176: Default Menu Items – Semantic HTML for ActionsIn the default menu items section, the component uses anchor (
<a>) elements withhref="#"to trigger actions. While this works functionally (with the@click.prevent.stopdirective), it is generally more semantically appropriate and accessible to use<button>elements for actions.Below is an example diff to switch from anchor tags to button elements:
-<a href="#" - class="block px-4 py-2 text-sm hover:bg-base-200" - @click.prevent.stop="open = false; $dispatch('edit-species', { index: safeIndex, listType: listType })"> - <div class="flex items-center gap-2"> - <!-- SVG icon and Edit text here --> - </div> -</a> +<button type="button" + class="block px-4 py-2 text-sm hover:bg-base-200" + @click.prevent.stop="open = false; $dispatch('edit-species', { index: safeIndex, listType: listType })"> + <div class="flex items-center gap-2"> + <!-- SVG icon and Edit text here --> + </div> +</button>A similar refactor could be applied to the Remove option.
views/components/speciesList.html (2)
38-45: Edit Mode Input HandlingThe conditional rendering of the
<input>element in edit mode is clear. The directives for model binding (x-model) and event handlers (for enter, escape, and blur) ensure interactive editing.Consider adding a placeholder or aria-label to the input for improved accessibility if the context is not clear from the surrounding UI.
47-67: Action Section with Conditional Template InclusionThe actions region smartly distinguishes between when a custom action template is provided versus falling back to a default remove button. One point worth noting is in the inline
x-datafor the action wrapper (line 51-54). The assignment forlistTypeis injected using Go templating. If.listTypeis expected to be a string, then it may be beneficial to wrap it in quotes to ensure valid JavaScript syntax. For example:- listType: {{if .listType}}{{.listType}}{{else}}null{{end}} + listType: {{if .listType}}"{{.listType}}"{{else}}null{{end}}This small change can prevent potential runtime errors when
.listTypeis a string.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (5)
assets/tailwind.css(6 hunks)views/components/speciesInput.html(1 hunks)views/components/speciesList.html(1 hunks)views/components/speciesListActionMenu.html(1 hunks)views/pages/settings/speciesSettings.html(13 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (2)
- views/components/speciesInput.html
- views/pages/settings/speciesSettings.html
⏰ Context from checks skipped due to timeout of 90000ms (2)
- GitHub Check: unit-tests
- GitHub Check: Analyze (go)
🔇 Additional comments (14)
assets/tailwind.css (4)
2371-2378: Review of the.badge-neutralutilityThis new block defines a neutral-style badge using design tokens for border, background, and text via the CSS variables
--fallback-nand--fallback-nc. The use of opacity variables and consistent naming is clear.Please verify that these values align with the rest of the badge variant definitions in your design system to maintain visual consistency.
5207-5210: Review of the.w-40utility classThe new
.w-40class correctly sets the width to10remand follows the responsive design approach by using rem units. This class matches the PR objective and the AI summary.Please double-check its usage across components to ensure consistent layout behavior.
6532-6534: Review of the responsive.md:w-36utilityThis block defines a medium-screen utility class that sets the width to
9rem. It is clear and aligns with the intended design system scale for responsive adjustments.Verify that this class is used consistently in components meant for medium screen sizes.
6548-6550: Review of the responsive.md:flex-rowutilityThe new
.md:flex-rowclass appliesflex-direction: rowon medium-sized screens, enhancing layout control in responsive designs. This addition supports the refactored UI components well.Ensure that components which rely on a horizontal arrangement properly include this utility.
views/components/speciesListActionMenu.html (5)
1-10: Component Documentation and Template DeclarationThe file header and inline documentation clearly describe the purpose of the component and its expected behavior. This level of detail is very useful for future maintainers.
11-52: x-data Initialization and Alpine Variables ScopeThe Alpine.js initialization block is well structured with functions for checking edit mode and updating the menu position. One point to verify is that the identifiers (
index,editIndex, and lateritem) used in the expressions are defined in the appropriate parent or inherited scope. If not, there could be runtime errors when these expressions are evaluated.Consider explicitly passing or defining these variables if they’re not inherited.
55-64: Action Button for Normal ModeThe toggle button that switches the dropdown display is implemented correctly with Alpine.js directives. The use of
x-show="notInEditMode()"and ensuring the menu position is updated on demand works well.
66-81: Edit Mode ButtonsThe Save and Cancel buttons in edit mode correctly dispatch their respective events with the appropriate payload. The use of
x-showcoupled withx-cloakensures these buttons aren’t visible unless needed.
83-94: Dropdown Menu Container and PositioningThe dropdown container leverages Alpine.js transitions and uses a fixed positioning strategy that calculates its vertical alignment based on available space. The logic inside
updatePosition()is clear and should perform reliably.views/components/speciesList.html (5)
1-15: Species List Template DocumentationThe template definition and usage documentation provide clear instructions on how to use the species list component. The parameters are well documented, which is excellent for maintainability and usability by other developers.
16-18: Dynamic Species Array Binding in x-for LoopThe
x-forloop correctly iterates over the species array. Please ensure that the server-side templating (i.e. the{{.species}}placeholder) outputs a properly serialized JavaScript array so that Alpine.js can iterate over it without issues.
19-28: Per-Item x-data Initialization and Edit State CheckThe initialization of
isEditingand thecheckEditState()method is a practical approach to maintain the per-item editing state. The conditional check using Go template directives (e.g.{{if .editIndex}}) correctly inserts the logic based on provided parameters.Optionally, verify that any value injected by
.editIndexis a valid JavaScript literal (e.g., a number) to avoid unintended type coercions.
32-36: Display Mode for Species NameThe display mode using a
<span>withx-show="!isEditing"and an inline expression forx-textis straightforward. The conditional use of.customDisplayis a neat way to allow custom formatting if needed.
62-67: Default Action FallbackThe default action fallback using a simple remove button is clear and provides a safe UI for species deletion. The use of
@click.preventto trigger the removal function keeps the behavior consistent.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
🧹 Nitpick comments (1)
views/pages/settings/settingsBase.html (1)
205-227: Comprehensive Component State Reset:
TheresetComponentChangesmethod successfully resets thehasChangesflags on the main component, the Alpine store, and individual child components. One note: accessing internal Alpine.js properties like_x_dataStackand_x_resetChangesmay be fragile if Alpine.js updates alter internal APIs. Consider checking if a public API or documented method is available for state resetting in future refactors.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (1)
views/pages/settings/settingsBase.html(4 hunks)
⏰ Context from checks skipped due to timeout of 90000ms (3)
- GitHub Check: unit-tests
- GitHub Check: Analyze (javascript-typescript)
- GitHub Check: Analyze (go)
🔇 Additional comments (4)
views/pages/settings/settingsBase.html (4)
94-96: Refactored Notification Handler:
The inline notification callback in theinitmethod now delegates to the_createNotificationmethod. This centralizes notification creation logic and helps reduce code duplication across the notification mechanisms.
126-149: Encapsulated Notification Creation:
The new_createNotificationmethod and the publicaddNotificationfunction effectively encapsulate the notification creation and removal logic. The unique ID generation usingDate.now() + Math.random()should work well in most scenarios, though consider potential (albeit unlikely) collisions in extremely rapid calls.
171-179: Robust Response Handling:
By checking thecontent-typeheader before parsing the response as JSON, the implementation gracefully handles non-JSON responses. This improves the resilience of the settings save operation.
189-193: User Notification for Security Settings Change:
The updated logic under the security settings block provides clear user feedback before triggering a page reload. The nested timeouts ensure the notification is visible to users. This user-centric approach is well implemented.
No description provided.